How To Choose the Best Mockumentary TV Shows

Mockumentaries have been a popular form of entertainment for decades, offering a unique blend of humor, satire, and social commentary. These shows, designed to mimic the style of documentaries while presenting fictional stories, often blur the line between reality and fiction, leading to a truly distinctive viewing experience. Whether you're a fan of comedies, dramas, or even horror, there's likely a mockumentary that suits your tastes. But with so many options available, how do you choose the best mockumentary TV shows? In this guide, we'll dive into the world of mockumentaries, providing tips on how to pick the perfect one for you based on various factors, including style, genre, tone, and cultural relevance.

Understanding Mockumentaries: The Basics

Mockumentaries, as the name suggests, are television shows or films that imitate the documentary format, often employing techniques like interviews, shaky camera work, and observational styles. However, unlike traditional documentaries, mockumentaries feature fictional or exaggerated storylines and characters. This style of storytelling often leads to absurd situations and humor, as the characters are typically portrayed in a deadpan, realistic manner, enhancing the comedic value.

The mockumentary format can be used across various genres, from comedy to drama and horror. Some mockumentaries take a lighthearted, satirical approach, while others use the format to explore deeper social or political themes. Popular examples include "The Office," "Parks and Recreation," "This Is Spinal Tap," and "What We Do in the Shadows."

Why Mockumentaries Work

The appeal of mockumentaries lies in their ability to play with expectations. Since viewers are familiar with the conventions of documentaries, they come to expect a certain level of seriousness, which makes the absurdity of fictional events and characters even funnier. The mockumentary style allows creators to blend reality with fiction, often making the viewer question what is real and what is staged. This mix of truth and fabrication adds layers to the storytelling and can be a brilliant method of social commentary or satire.

Key Elements to Consider When Choosing a Mockumentary

1. Genre and Tone

The genre of the mockumentary plays a major role in determining whether it will resonate with you. Mockumentaries can span several genres, each offering a different kind of experience.

• Comedy: This is the most popular genre for mockumentaries, and most people associate mockumentaries with sitcoms like The Office or Parks and Recreation. These shows use humor to highlight the absurdities of everyday life, often involving quirky characters, awkward social situations, and dry humor.
• Drama: Some mockumentaries take a more serious approach, blending humor with drama to create a compelling narrative. The Comeback, for example, mixes emotional depth with comedic moments to explore the struggles of a washed-up actress trying to make a comeback.
• Horror: Mockumentaries can also be used in horror to create a sense of unease and tension. What We Do in the Shadows is a brilliant example of blending horror with comedy in a mockumentary style.
• Satire and Social Commentary: A number of mockumentaries focus on satirical portrayals of specific social issues, politics, or cultural phenomena. These shows often use the documentary format to highlight the absurdity of certain real-world issues.

When choosing a mockumentary, it's crucial to identify the genre that best matches your mood or interests. If you're looking for light-hearted humor, comedy mockumentaries are a great choice. If you prefer something with more emotional depth or a critical view of society, a drama or satirical mockumentary might be the way to go.

2. Character Development and Acting

Character development is crucial in mockumentary TV shows because the humor often comes from the characters' interactions and the way they react to absurd situations. Strong, well-developed characters make the world feel more immersive and contribute to the realism of the show. A good mockumentary often involves characters who are eccentric, memorable, and complex, even though they're part of a fictional world.

The actors also play a significant role in making a mockumentary successful. Since these shows usually feature deadpan humor, the ability to deliver lines with a straight face while portraying over-the-top characters is an essential skill. The best mockumentaries feature strong comedic performances that complement the documentary style, making the absurdities of the situation feel grounded in reality.

3. Social Relevance and Cultural Commentary

Mockumentaries often have a strong undercurrent of social commentary, using humor and satire to critique various aspects of society, from politics to pop culture. When choosing a mockumentary, consider how relevant the show's themes are to your interests or the cultural context in which it was created.

For instance, The Office (U.S.) uses the setting of a mundane office environment to explore human relationships, work dynamics, and the sometimes ridiculous nature of corporate life. Similarly, Parks and Recreation critiques local government and bureaucracy while highlighting the personal growth of its characters.

If you enjoy shows that offer insightful commentary on modern society or issues that resonate with you, look for mockumentaries that tackle topics that interest you, whether it's workplace culture, celebrity, politics, or social media.

4. Humor Style and Delivery

Humor is the central component of most mockumentaries, but the style of humor can vary widely from one show to another. While some mockumentaries rely on dry humor, awkward silences, and cringe-worthy moments, others may use slapstick or absurd humor for a more lighthearted feel. Depending on your comedic tastes, you may prefer one type of humor over another.

• Dry Humor/Deadpan Comedy: Many mockumentaries, like The Office or Arrested Development, use dry humor to create awkward situations where characters act as if nothing out of the ordinary is happening, even when the absurdity is clear to the audience. This type of humor is often characterized by a slow pace, subtle punchlines, and an emphasis on awkward social interactions.
• Absurd Humor: Shows like What We Do in the Shadows or Trailer Park Boys lean more towards absurd humor, where the characters exist in a world that is deliberately strange or over-the-top. The humor often stems from the characters' bizarre behavior and interactions in improbable situations.
• Cringe Comedy: Shows like The Office and The Comeback thrive on cringe humor, where the audience feels embarrassed for the characters due to their socially awkward behavior, lack of self-awareness, or uncomfortable situations. If you enjoy watching characters navigate uncomfortable moments with no filter, cringe comedy might be your go-to.

Understanding your preferred humor style is key to selecting a mockumentary that aligns with your tastes. If you're someone who enjoys subtle wit and awkwardness, go for a show with dry humor. If you prefer more outlandish, over-the-top comedy, an absurd mockumentary is a better fit.

5. Pacing and Length

The pacing and length of a mockumentary show can affect how engaging it is. Some mockumentaries are fast-paced, with short, snappy episodes that keep the humor flowing without dragging on. Others take a slower approach, developing characters and plotlines over time to build a more nuanced and long-term narrative.

If you have limited time or prefer shorter episodes, you might want to choose a mockumentary that has shorter seasons or episodes. On the other hand, if you enjoy getting immersed in a world over several seasons, shows with deeper plots and slower pacing might be more up your alley.

6. Cult Following and Popularity

Many mockumentaries gain a cult following due to their unique blend of humor and social commentary. When choosing a mockumentary, consider whether the show has a strong fanbase or if it has been widely praised by critics. Cult classics like The Office or Trailer Park Boys may offer a greater sense of community, as fans often enjoy discussing the characters and moments from these shows in great detail.

It's also worth considering the popularity of a show within certain circles. If you're looking for something that has been widely appreciated and talked about, mainstream mockumentaries might be the best choice. However, if you're looking for something a bit more niche or under-the-radar, there are plenty of lesser-known mockumentaries that offer unique perspectives and humor.

Top Mockumentary TV Shows to Watch

To help you choose, here are some top-rated mockumentaries across various genres:

1. The Office (U.S.) -- A workplace comedy about a group of office workers at Dunder Mifflin, The Office uses dry humor and awkward moments to depict the mundane and sometimes absurd nature of corporate life.
2. Parks and Recreation -- Set in a fictional town, this mockumentary follows the quirky employees of the Parks and Recreation department, focusing on the determined Leslie Knope and her eccentric colleagues.
3. What We Do in the Shadows -- This hilarious horror mockumentary follows a group of vampires living in modern-day New York, balancing their ancient supernatural lives with mundane human struggles.
4. Trailer Park Boys -- This Canadian series follows the misadventures of a group of petty criminals in a trailer park, combining absurd humor with sharp social satire.
5. The Comeback -- A dramedy about an aging TV star trying to make a comeback, The Comeback uses mockumentary-style storytelling to explore Hollywood's treatment of women and aging.
6. Documentary Now! -- A parody of various documentary styles, Documentary Now! spoofs famous documentaries and features different fictional stories with a comedic twist.
7. Summer Heights High -- A mockumentary about a high school in Australia, Summer Heights High follows the lives of teachers and students with outrageous characters and humor.

Conclusion

Choosing the best mockumentary TV show comes down to understanding your preferences in genre, humor, character development, and social commentary. Whether you're drawn to dry humor, absurd situations, or satirical commentary, there's a mockumentary that will meet your needs. By considering the elements outlined above, you can find a show that not only entertains but also provides thoughtful reflections on society and human nature. So, dive into the world of mockumentaries, and enjoy the fun, laughter, and sometimes uncomfortable truths that they bring!

View Product