How to Write Historical Fiction Without Getting It Wrong

Writing historical fiction is a delicate balancing act between creativity and accuracy. As a genre, historical fiction allows writers to step back in time, blending fact with fiction to create compelling narratives set in the past. However, it comes with an inherent responsibility: the story should feel authentic and respectful to the time period it represents. While writers are not bound by historical fact, it is crucial not to distort history in ways that might mislead readers or trivialize significant events. So, how can authors craft engaging historical fiction without getting it wrong?

In this article, we'll explore the key considerations and strategies for writing historical fiction that both resonates with readers and respects the past. By understanding the essential aspects of history, mastering the nuances of historical context, and incorporating elements of fiction in a way that feels organic, writers can successfully navigate the complexities of the genre.

Understanding the Foundation: Research

The foundation of historical fiction is research. Without a solid understanding of the time period, setting, and events you're writing about, your narrative will lack depth and authenticity.

1. Why Research is Crucial

Good historical fiction is built upon a strong research foundation. Writers need to immerse themselves in the time period they are writing about, understanding the key events, social norms, politics, customs, language, and daily life of the time. This research serves not only as a backdrop but also informs character development, plotlines, and dialogue.

If you are writing about World War II, for instance, you need to understand the global political climate, the role of various countries, the experience of ordinary citizens during wartime, and how the war affected people on a personal level. Similarly, writing about the Victorian era requires understanding the rigid social hierarchies, the technological advancements, and the societal expectations of the time.

2. Where to Start with Research

Research doesn't just mean reading history books. Depending on your specific focus, you can dive into a variety of resources:

• Primary Sources: Letters, diaries, government documents, newspaper articles, and other firsthand accounts from the time are invaluable. They provide direct insight into the thoughts, behaviors, and attitudes of people living during that period.
• Secondary Sources: Books, academic papers, and documentaries by historians and experts provide context and analysis of historical events, figures, and trends.
• Visual Resources: Old photographs, paintings, films, and advertisements can provide clues to fashion, architecture, and the visual culture of the time.
• Historical Fiction: Reading well-researched historical novels by other authors can also help you understand how to blend historical fact with fiction while maintaining accuracy.

3. Fact vs. Fiction: Striking the Right Balance

While it's important to stick to historical facts, historical fiction allows writers to inject creativity into their work. The goal is to create a story that feels grounded in its historical setting while allowing for fictional exploration. Here's how you can strike that balance:

• Historical Accuracy: Stick to the key events, dates, and factual details, especially for major events and prominent historical figures. Factual inaccuracies in critical moments, like the dates of wars or the role of historical figures, can easily break the suspension of disbelief.
• Fictional Freedom: Create fictional characters, events, or subplots that don't alter or distort the course of actual history. These elements can enhance the story and give it depth, but they should never overshadow or rewrite the historical facts.
• Avoid Anachronisms: Anachronisms are elements that are out of place in the time period. For example, having a character use a modern expression or discuss events that hadn't occurred yet is a mistake. Pay attention to the language, clothing, technology, and cultural norms of the period.

Developing Authentic Characters

In historical fiction, characters are the heartbeat of the story. Creating authentic characters who feel like they belong in the historical context you've set them in is critical to the success of your narrative.

1. Know the Social and Cultural Norms

Your characters should reflect the values, social expectations, and gender roles of the time. In many historical periods, for instance, women's roles were vastly different from those of men, and this social dynamic needs to be accurately portrayed. Consider the historical restrictions, personal choices, and opportunities available to your characters based on their social class, gender, and nationality.

If your novel is set during the Regency period in England, for example, a young woman would have very different opportunities from a man, particularly in terms of marriage, social expectations, and education. A historically accurate portrayal of such a character requires a nuanced understanding of these societal structures.

2. Speech and Dialogue

One of the most challenging aspects of writing historical fiction is crafting authentic dialogue. Modern language and idioms will immediately take readers out of the world you've built. While you don't need to write in old-fashioned, overly formal language, you should consider how people of the era spoke.

Study period-appropriate language, idioms, and speech patterns. For example, in the 18th century, people may have used formal greetings like "Your Grace" or "Sir," and employed phrases such as "I dare say" or "By my troth." Similarly, the way people express emotions, ask for help, or describe their surroundings should be consistent with the time period.

However, don't overdo it. Dialogue should still be accessible to modern readers. Aim for a balance between historical accuracy and readability, using language that feels true to the time but doesn't alienate the audience.

3. Emotions and Motivation

Historical figures and characters, though shaped by their time, are also human beings with emotions, desires, and fears. While historical context will influence their behavior and attitudes, don't forget to explore their inner lives. What motivates them? What are their struggles? The core of great historical fiction lies in the emotional truth of its characters.

Consider how different historical circumstances affect characters' psychology. For instance, a soldier during the American Civil War may be driven by a sense of duty, fear, or a personal vendetta. Similarly, a woman in ancient Greece might struggle with the expectations placed on her by society while secretly yearning for freedom or self-expression.

Crafting the Plot and Setting

Historical fiction is deeply entwined with the setting and plot. The world in which your characters live must be vividly realized, and the events of history must provide a backdrop that shapes the characters' lives.

1. Using Real Events as a Foundation

One way to avoid historical inaccuracies is to base your plot on real historical events. Wars, revolutions, political shifts, and social movements all provide rich material for stories. When you do this, make sure to research the event in detail, including the underlying causes, key figures involved, and the consequences. Don't simply use history as a backdrop---let it drive the plot and influence the characters' actions.

For example, a novel set during the French Revolution could feature a fictional family caught up in the upheaval, with their fates intertwined with real historical figures like Robespierre or Napoleon. Your characters could experience the chaos and violence of the revolution firsthand, giving readers a personal, human perspective on the historical event.

2. Inventing Subplots

While major events should stay true to history, inventing subplots that explore the impact of these events on individuals can add depth to your narrative. For instance, a story about the sinking of the Titanic could center on a fictional romance between two passengers from different social classes, adding emotional resonance to the tragedy.

These subplots should, however, remain consistent with the historical reality. Avoid making dramatic changes to the events that would distort the factual record. If you introduce a fictional love affair or conspiracy, ensure it's plausible within the framework of the time period.

3. Creating the Setting

The setting is more than just the backdrop for your plot---it should almost become a character in its own right. The environment, landscapes, architecture, and even the weather can reflect the tone of the story and give it atmosphere.

In historical fiction, settings should be meticulously researched. For example, if your story takes place in medieval England, ensure that the details of the castle, clothing, food, and customs are accurate to the period. Don't overlook small details like the types of furniture in a royal court or the way people travel from one place to another. These authentic touches help immerse readers in the world you've created.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls in Historical Fiction

Writing historical fiction can be an exhilarating creative endeavor, but there are several common pitfalls to avoid.

1. Over-Romanticizing History

It's easy to romanticize the past, but be careful not to idealize it in a way that distorts historical facts. For example, writing a story about a "simpler time" may overlook the hardships, inequalities, and challenges faced by people in the past. Avoid glossing over issues like social injustice, racism, or inequality just for the sake of nostalgia or drama.

2. Using Fiction to Push a Political Agenda

Historical fiction can be a powerful tool for examining political and social issues, but it's important not to distort the past to fit a modern political agenda. Be cautious about rewriting history for the sake of making a contemporary point. While it's acceptable to draw parallels between historical events and modern issues, ensure that your portrayal of history is true to the time.

3. Overloading the Narrative with Historical Details

While accuracy is important, too much historical information can overwhelm the story and bore the reader. Focus on weaving the historical details naturally into the narrative, using them to enhance the characters' experiences and motivations. Don't let the history overshadow the plot or make the narrative feel like a history lesson.

Conclusion

Writing historical fiction without getting it wrong requires a deep respect for history, a commitment to thorough research, and a delicate balance between factual accuracy and creative freedom. By grounding your story in real historical events, creating authentic characters, and crafting a vivid setting, you can bring the past to life in a way that resonates with readers. While the task may be challenging, the rewards of creating a captivating and accurate historical narrative are immense. By honoring the past and respecting its complexities, you'll be able to craft stories that entertain, educate, and inspire.

View Product