How To Identify Red Herrings in Film

In the world of cinema, filmmakers often use a technique known as the "red herring" to mislead the audience and keep them on the edge of their seats. Whether you're watching a suspenseful thriller, a mystery, or even a drama, red herrings are employed to divert attention, confuse viewers, and build tension. Understanding how red herrings work in film not only enhances the viewing experience but also sharpens the critical thinking of the audience. In this article, we will explore how red herrings function in cinema, how to identify them, and why they are so effective in storytelling.

What is a Red Herring?

A red herring is a literary and cinematic device designed to mislead or distract the audience from the true narrative. Originating from the world of literature, this technique is often associated with mystery and thriller genres, where the audience is trying to solve a puzzle or uncover a hidden truth. The term "red herring" comes from the practice of using a smoked fish with a strong odor to mislead hunting dogs. The fish would create a false trail, leading the dogs away from their original scent.

In the context of film, a red herring serves the same purpose: it leads the audience down a false path, guiding them toward incorrect conclusions about characters, events, or motives. The goal is to create confusion and suspense, enhancing the impact of the actual revelation when it occurs. By the time the red herring is unveiled, the audience is often left stunned, as they realize they have been tricked.

The Role of Red Herrings in Film

Red herrings play an essential role in various types of films, especially those that rely on mystery, suspense, or surprise twists. They are used to create tension and keep the audience engaged by introducing uncertainty and ambiguity. A well-placed red herring can elevate the emotional intensity of a scene and make the eventual payoff all the more satisfying.

In mystery films, red herrings are often used to complicate the investigation and obscure the identity of the real perpetrator. In thrillers, they can divert attention from the true danger or threat, leading characters and viewers to focus on the wrong clue or suspect. In psychological dramas, red herrings may be used to cast doubt on a character's motivations, creating a sense of paranoia.

The effectiveness of a red herring depends on its ability to mislead without feeling forced or contrived. A poorly executed red herring can feel like an obvious cheat, breaking the immersion of the film. A skillful red herring, however, can add layers of complexity to the story, encouraging viewers to re-evaluate their assumptions and interpretations.

How Red Herrings Are Used in Different Genres

1. Mystery and Detective Films

In the mystery genre, red herrings are practically a requirement. They are used to keep the detective (and the audience) guessing and to ensure that the revelation of the true culprit is delayed until the right moment. Classic examples of red herrings can be found in the works of Agatha Christie, such as Murder on the Orient Express, where multiple suspects are introduced, and the audience is led to believe one person is guilty, only to be proven wrong at the end.

In modern detective films, like Knives Out or The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, filmmakers often introduce red herrings in the form of suspicious characters, misleading evidence, or contradictory witness testimonies. These false leads create a sense of confusion and challenge the audience to think critically about the clues presented.

2. Thrillers and Suspense Films

Thriller films often rely on red herrings to misdirect the audience's focus, especially when it comes to creating a false sense of security or danger. For example, in films like The Sixth Sense or Shutter Island, red herrings are strategically placed to divert attention from the twist ending. Characters, plot details, and seemingly significant events may all be designed to mislead the viewer.

In suspense films, red herrings heighten the tension by providing false resolutions or potential threats. In The Others, for instance, the audience is led to believe one thing about the nature of the supernatural events, only to be confronted with a startling twist that reframes everything that came before.

3. Psychological and Character-driven Dramas

In psychological films, red herrings are often used to confuse the viewer's perception of characters, their motivations, or their sanity. Films like Black Swan or Gone Girl feature unreliable characters whose actions and motivations are deliberately ambiguous. These films may present situations or clues that lead the audience to draw the wrong conclusions about the character's behavior.

Red herrings in psychological dramas may also revolve around themes of memory, perception, or identity. In Memento, for example, the audience is led through a fragmented narrative that encourages them to question what is real and what is fabricated. The red herrings in this film serve to reinforce the sense of disorientation felt by the protagonist and the audience alike.

4. Horror Films

In horror films, red herrings are often used to play with the audience's expectations regarding the identity of the villain or the true source of fear. Classic examples include The Blair Witch Project and Psycho, where viewers are introduced to multiple potential threats or suspects, only to have the actual danger revealed later.

In some cases, red herrings in horror films can serve to build suspense or mislead the audience about the nature of the supernatural forces at play. The audience may be led to believe that a particular character is the monster or antagonist, only to discover that the true villain is something entirely different.

Identifying Red Herrings in Film

Identifying red herrings in films requires a keen eye and an understanding of the narrative techniques employed by filmmakers. Here are some key ways to spot red herrings in films:

1. Overemphasis on a Particular Clue or Character

One of the most common indicators of a red herring is when a particular clue, character, or piece of information is overly emphasized or presented as suspicious. Filmmakers will often linger on a detail or individual in a way that makes them seem important. This is a signal to the audience that the clue or character might not be what they appear to be. By making something appear too obvious, filmmakers are often setting it up as a misdirection.

For instance, in a mystery film, a character who is repeatedly shown in close-up shots or given significant screen time might seem like the prime suspect, only for the true culprit to be someone who received less attention.

2. Contradictory or Conflicting Information

Another way to identify a red herring is by looking for contradictions or conflicting information within the story. In mystery films, for example, multiple characters may provide conflicting testimonies or evidence that casts doubt on the investigation. These contradictions are usually designed to mislead the audience into believing a false theory.

If a character's actions seem out of place or are inconsistent with their motivations, it may be a sign that they are a red herring. Filmmakers will often intentionally create ambiguity about a character's intentions, leading the audience to believe they are hiding something, only to later reveal that the character was not involved in the central mystery.

3. The Character Who is Too Good or Too Evil

In many films, characters who appear too perfect or too villainous are often red herrings. A seemingly perfect character, with few flaws or vulnerabilities, may be hiding something that the audience is unaware of. Similarly, a character who is portrayed as overly evil or suspicious may turn out to be a victim of circumstance or manipulation.

In these cases, filmmakers intentionally exaggerate the character's traits to mislead the audience into drawing conclusions based on surface-level observations. These characters often end up being less important than they first appear, with the true resolution of the story lying elsewhere.

4. Inconsequential Subplots or Tangents

Red herrings can also be found in seemingly inconsequential subplots or tangents that take the audience's attention away from the central narrative. These tangents may be inserted into the story to distract from the main mystery or conflict. In many cases, they are deliberately left unresolved, creating a sense of confusion or uncertainty.

For example, a subplot involving a secondary character's personal life or an unrelated event may seem important at first, but ultimately has little to do with the main story. The purpose of these subplots is to keep the audience focused on the wrong things, allowing the true resolution to sneak up on them.

Why Red Herrings Are Effective in Film

Red herrings are highly effective in film because they play on the audience's expectations and their desire to solve the mystery. They keep viewers engaged by providing false clues and leading them down a false path. When the true resolution is finally revealed, the audience feels a sense of satisfaction and surprise, as they realize how the red herrings had misled them.

Additionally, red herrings create a more immersive viewing experience by encouraging the audience to think critically about what is happening on screen. The constant uncertainty and ambiguity make the story feel more dynamic and unpredictable, enhancing the emotional impact of the film.

Red herrings also contribute to the thematic complexity of a film. By introducing multiple layers of confusion and misdirection, filmmakers can explore themes of deception, trust, and perception. In many cases, the red herrings themselves become symbolic of the characters' internal struggles or the larger societal issues being addressed in the film.

Conclusion

Red herrings are a vital narrative device in film, playing a crucial role in creating suspense, confusion, and surprise. By intentionally misleading the audience and leading them down false paths, filmmakers enhance the storytelling experience, making the eventual revelation all the more impactful. Understanding how red herrings work and how to identify them allows viewers to engage with films on a deeper level, heightening both their enjoyment and their critical thinking skills.

While red herrings may seem like mere tricks, they are an essential part of cinematic storytelling, shaping how we experience narratives and leaving us with lingering questions long after the credits roll. Whether you're watching a detective film, a thriller, or a psychological drama, spotting the red herrings can be as rewarding as uncovering the true mystery itself.

View Product