How to Identify Faults and Flaws in Wine

Wine, often seen as a sophisticated and elegant beverage, is not immune to imperfections. From improper storage to contamination during production, faults and flaws can manifest in various ways that can significantly affect the overall experience of tasting and drinking wine. Identifying these issues requires a discerning palate, an understanding of the winemaking process, and the ability to differentiate between natural variations in wine and true defects.

In this article, we'll delve into the common faults and flaws that affect wine, explore the reasons behind them, and offer practical advice on how to identify them. Whether you're a wine enthusiast, sommelier, or winemaker, understanding these flaws will enhance your ability to evaluate wines more thoroughly.

Understanding Wine Faults and Flaws

Before identifying faults and flaws, it's important to define the difference between the two. A fault refers to a serious defect in the wine that typically arises from contamination or poor winemaking practices, while a flaw is a more subtle imperfection that doesn't necessarily ruin the wine but can detract from its overall quality.

In the world of wine, most faults are caused by factors that can be controlled during the winemaking process. However, some are the result of natural processes, such as oxidation or cork taint, which may occur during storage or bottling. Knowing how to recognize these faults and flaws will allow you to identify problematic bottles and ensure that your wine experience is as enjoyable as possible.

Common Wine Faults

1. Cork Taint (TCA Contamination)

Cork taint, caused by a chemical compound known as TCA (2,4,6-trichloroanisole), is one of the most notorious faults in wine. This fault is caused when the cork, typically made from natural bark, becomes contaminated with TCA. As a result, the wine may take on a musty, moldy odor reminiscent of wet cardboard or a damp basement. In severe cases, this can mask the true aromas and flavors of the wine, making it unpleasant to drink.

How to Identify Cork Taint

• Smell: The primary indicator of cork taint is the musty, moldy odor. If a wine smells like wet cardboard, old newspaper, or moldy wood, it is likely contaminated with TCA.
• Taste: In addition to the smell, a wine affected by cork taint often tastes flat, dull, and lifeless. The fruit flavors may be muted or completely absent.

2. Oxidation

Oxidation occurs when the wine is exposed to oxygen for too long, causing it to undergo chemical changes that degrade its quality. While a small amount of oxygen exposure can be beneficial for aging, excessive oxidation leads to a wine that is flat, stale, and lacks its fresh, vibrant characteristics. Oxidized wine often has a brownish color and a taste of bruised or overripe fruit, along with a flat, lifeless texture.

How to Identify Oxidation

• Appearance: Oxidized wine may have a brownish hue, especially white wines that should typically be clear or pale yellow. Red wines can also develop a dull, brownish color as a result of oxidation.
• Smell and Taste: Oxidized wine will often have aromas of bruised or cooked fruit, and the taste will lack freshness. It may also have a flat or watery mouthfeel.

3. Brettanomyces (Brett)

Brettanomyces, or "Brett" for short, is a wild yeast that can infect wine during fermentation or aging. While some winemakers deliberately encourage Brett for specific styles, particularly in red wines, excessive levels of this yeast can create unpleasant flavors and aromas. Brett can produce barnyard-like smells, reminiscent of sweaty leather, horse stable, or wet wool. While small amounts of Brett may be desirable in some wine styles (such as some Rhône wines), high levels can overpower the wine and make it undrinkable.

How to Identify Brett

• Smell: The most distinctive sign of Brett contamination is the presence of barnyard or earthy smells. These can range from subtle hints of leather or spice to overpowering aromas of manure, sweat, or wet hay.
• Taste: Wines with high levels of Brett often have a taste that is equally earthy, with flavors that may be described as "dirty" or "animal-like." The wine can also feel unbalanced, with a reduction in fruitiness and vibrancy.

4. Volatile Acidity (VA)

Volatile acidity refers to the presence of acetic acid and other acidic compounds that contribute to the sharp, sour notes in a wine. While a small amount of volatile acidity can add complexity and balance to a wine, excessive VA leads to a wine that is unbalanced and unpleasant. This fault is often associated with poor winemaking practices, such as improper fermentation or contamination by acetic acid bacteria.

How to Identify Volatile Acidity

• Smell: High levels of VA can produce strong vinegar-like aromas, with hints of nail polish remover or sour, rotting fruit.
• Taste: On the palate, volatile acidity can cause a sharp, biting sensation, often described as a "vinegar" or "sour" taste. It can make the wine feel unbalanced and harsh.

5. Reduction

A reductive wine is one that has been exposed to insufficient oxygen during fermentation or aging. This can result in a wine that has unpleasant aromas of rotten eggs, rubber, or burnt matches. While some reduction can occur naturally, excessive reduction can lead to overpowering off-flavors that mask the wine's true character.

How to Identify Reduction

• Smell: A reduced wine will often have a strong, sulfur-like odor, similar to that of struck matches, burnt rubber, or rotten eggs. These smells can be quite off-putting.
• Taste: Reduced wines can also have a heavy, dense mouthfeel with flavors of rubber, struck match, or burnt plastic.

Common Wine Flaws

1. Maderization

Maderization occurs when wine is exposed to heat, causing it to undergo a chemical reaction that leads to the development of cooked or stewed flavors. This is a flaw that is commonly associated with wine that has been improperly stored or subjected to extreme temperatures, such as in transit or poor cellar conditions.

How to Identify Maderization

• Appearance: Maderized wines often take on a darker, amber color, especially white wines that should be pale.
• Smell and Taste: The aromas of maderized wine are often cooked, stewed, or jammy, with notes of caramelized fruit, overripe berries, or burnt sugar. The taste is similarly affected, with a flat, overly sweet or syrupy profile.

2. Over-Oaking

Over-oaking occurs when wine is aged in oak barrels for too long or in too large quantities of oak. While oak aging can add complexity and depth to wine, excessive oak influence can overpower the wine's natural flavors. Wines affected by over-oaking often have strong, woody flavors that overshadow the fruit, as well as unpleasant aromas of vanilla, smoke, or sawdust.

How to Identify Over-Oaking

• Smell: Wines that are over-oaked often have a pronounced aroma of vanilla, smoke, or wood, which can overpower the fruit.
• Taste: The flavors of over-oaked wines are often woody and tannic, with an excessive amount of spice or smokiness that can dominate the wine's natural fruit characteristics.

3. Tannic or Astringent Wines

While tannins are an essential part of red wine and contribute to structure and aging potential, wines with excessively high tannins can feel harsh and astringent. This flaw is typically a result of over-extraction during the winemaking process, such as too much maceration or fermentation at too high a temperature.

How to Identify Tannic or Astringent Wines

• Taste: Tannic wines often cause a dry, puckering sensation on the gums and tongue. The wine may feel overly astringent, with little balance between the tannins and the fruit.
• Mouthfeel: Excessively tannic wines may feel coarse or aggressive in the mouth, making them difficult to enjoy, particularly if they are not balanced with sufficient fruit or acidity.

4. Bitter or Metallic Tastes

A bitter or metallic taste in wine is usually a result of contamination during the winemaking process, such as the use of tainted equipment or exposure to certain chemicals. This flaw is particularly common in wines that have been stored in poorly cleaned barrels or tanks.

How to Identify Bitter or Metallic Tastes

• Taste: A bitter or metallic flavor in wine is usually harsh, with notes of metal, rust, or an unappealing sharpness.
• Mouthfeel: These wines can leave an unpleasant aftertaste, making them difficult to drink.

Conclusion

Identifying faults and flaws in wine is an essential skill for anyone who enjoys or works with wine. Whether you're a casual drinker or a professional sommelier, recognizing the signs of issues like cork taint, oxidation, or excessive tannins can significantly enhance your ability to appreciate wine. By understanding the causes behind these defects and learning how to identify them through smell, taste, and appearance, you can ensure that every bottle you encounter delivers a satisfying and enjoyable experience.

While wine faults and flaws are common, they are by no means the norm. With proper storage, careful winemaking, and attention to detail, the vast majority of wines will deliver the vibrant, expressive qualities that wine lovers crave. So, the next time you uncork a bottle, take a moment to appreciate not just the flavor but also the complexities that lie within, and remember that identifying wine faults is as much about refining your palate as it is about understanding the art of winemaking.

View Product