How to Create a Checklist for Negotiating Non-Compete and Confidentiality Clauses in Partnerships

When entering a partnership, whether it's for a business, consultancy, or any other professional collaboration, it's essential to protect both your interests and those of your partners. Non-compete and confidentiality clauses are common components of partnership agreements designed to safeguard sensitive information, intellectual property, and market positioning. However, these clauses can be complex and may impact your future opportunities or business growth if not negotiated carefully.

To ensure that these clauses work in your favor, it's crucial to have a checklist that will guide you through the negotiation process. Below, we explore an actionable guide for creating a checklist that will help you negotiate non-compete and confidentiality clauses effectively and responsibly.

Understand the Purpose of Non-Compete and Confidentiality Clauses

Before diving into the negotiation process, it's important to understand what each clause aims to accomplish.

Non-Compete Clause

A non-compete clause restricts one party from engaging in business activities that directly compete with the other party's business during and sometimes after the partnership ends. The purpose of this clause is to protect business interests, including trade secrets, customer relationships, and proprietary knowledge, ensuring that neither party takes advantage of these assets for personal gain after the partnership concludes.

Confidentiality Clause

A confidentiality clause, or non-disclosure agreement (NDA), protects sensitive information shared between partners during the course of the partnership. This may include intellectual property, client lists, business strategies, financial details, or other proprietary data. By having a confidentiality clause, both parties are legally bound to keep specific information private.

Define Your Objectives and Boundaries

Before entering negotiations, take some time to clearly define your objectives and boundaries regarding these clauses. Ask yourself the following questions:

• What are my concerns with competition after the partnership?

  Are you worried about a partner potentially starting a competing business or taking clients with them once the partnership ends?

• What sensitive information do I need to protect?

  Identify the proprietary knowledge or trade secrets that you want to keep confidential. This may include client data, marketing strategies, and business processes.

• What is a reasonable timeframe for these clauses?

  Consider how long it's acceptable for a non-compete agreement to last after the partnership ends. Similarly, what is the duration for keeping information confidential?

These questions will help you articulate your priorities and create a list of non-negotiables and areas of flexibility.

Key Components of a Non-Compete Clause to Negotiate

When negotiating a non-compete clause, focus on the key components that can affect your ability to operate freely post-partnership. Here's a breakdown of important factors to include in your checklist:

A. Scope of the Non-Compete

• What constitutes competition?
  Ensure that the clause clearly defines what constitutes direct competition. Vague language can lead to confusion or misinterpretation down the line.
• Geographic restrictions
  Negotiate for reasonable geographic limits. A global restriction could limit your ability to operate in other markets. Consider negotiating regional or industry-specific boundaries that won't unduly hinder your future activities.

B. Duration

• How long will the restriction last?
  Non-compete clauses often last between 6 months to 2 years. The shorter the duration, the better. Prolonged restrictions can be detrimental to your career or business prospects. A period of 1 year is often reasonable, but this varies depending on the industry.

C. Specificity of Activities

• What activities are restricted?
  Be specific about the activities that are prohibited post-partnership. This could include starting a similar business, working for a competitor, or soliciting former clients. The broader the restriction, the harder it will be to work freely in your field after the partnership ends.

D. Exceptions and Exemptions

• What are the exceptions to the non-compete clause?
  Negotiate for flexibility, especially if there are circumstances under which you may want to work in a related field or market. This might include exemption clauses, such as continuing in a non-competing business or partnership that was in place before the agreement was signed.

E. Enforcement and Remedies

• What are the enforcement mechanisms?
  Make sure the non-compete clause is enforceable in the jurisdiction where you plan to operate post-partnership. Additionally, clarify the consequences of breaching the clause and whether any penalties are disproportionate or unreasonable.

Key Components of a Confidentiality Clause to Negotiate

Confidentiality clauses are essential for protecting sensitive business information. To create an effective confidentiality agreement, ensure you cover the following key components:

A. Definition of Confidential Information

• What constitutes confidential information?
  Be specific about what is considered confidential. This might include business plans, client data, financial records, intellectual property, or employee details. General language like "all information shared during the partnership" may be too vague, so clearly delineate what is covered.

B. Obligations of the Parties

• What are the obligations of each partner regarding confidentiality?
  Specify the obligations to safeguard confidential information. Ensure the clause requires that each party makes a reasonable effort to protect confidential information, such as restricting access to a need-to-know basis.

C. Duration of Confidentiality

• How long must information be kept confidential?
  Confidentiality obligations should extend beyond the partnership's duration, particularly if proprietary information is involved. The confidentiality period might range from a few years to indefinite, depending on the type of information being protected. Typically, a confidentiality period of 2-5 years after the partnership ends is reasonable.

D. Exceptions to Confidentiality

• Are there exceptions to the confidentiality clause?
  There may be instances where disclosure of confidential information is necessary, such as if required by law or court order. Ensure that the clause allows for these exceptions while still protecting the primary confidentiality of sensitive materials.

E. Return or Destruction of Confidential Information

• What happens to confidential information after the partnership ends?
  Specify that all confidential information must be returned or destroyed upon termination of the partnership. This protects both parties and ensures that neither party retains proprietary data after the relationship ends.

Additional Considerations

While non-compete and confidentiality clauses are often the focal point, there are a few other important considerations that should be addressed in the partnership agreement:

A. Right to Review and Approve

• Can you review and approve future partnerships or clients your partner enters into?
  Some partnership agreements may allow partners to approve new ventures or business relationships that could potentially conflict with the existing partnership.

B. Dispute Resolution

• How will disputes regarding these clauses be resolved?
  Include a dispute resolution mechanism in case of disagreements over the interpretation or enforcement of the non-compete or confidentiality clauses. This might include mediation or arbitration, which can save time and legal costs compared to litigation.

C. Severability

• What happens if a part of the clause is deemed unenforceable?
  Ensure that the agreement includes a severability clause. This ensures that if a court finds any part of the non-compete or confidentiality clauses unenforceable, the rest of the agreement remains intact.

Consult with Legal Counsel

It's always advisable to consult with an attorney before finalizing any partnership agreement, especially when it involves complex clauses like non-compete and confidentiality provisions. A legal expert can help tailor these clauses to suit your specific situation, ensuring that they are both fair and enforceable.

Conclusion

Negotiating non-compete and confidentiality clauses in partnership agreements is a critical step that can protect your business and future opportunities. By following a detailed checklist and considering all the key components outlined above, you can enter into a partnership with confidence. Always approach these negotiations with a clear understanding of your goals, and be sure to seek legal counsel to ensure that these clauses are balanced and in your best interest.

View Product