10 Tips for Using DNA Testing to Break Through Brick Walls

Genealogy research can sometimes be frustrating, especially when you hit a "brick wall" --- a point where traditional research methods seem to stall. DNA testing can provide a powerful tool to break through these barriers, helping to reveal hidden family connections and discover ancestors that were previously unknown. Whether you're a novice genealogist or an experienced researcher, DNA testing can significantly enhance your family tree and help fill in the gaps of your heritage.

In this article, we will explore 10 essential tips for using DNA testing to break through brick walls in genealogy research. From selecting the right DNA test to interpreting results, these strategies will help you make the most of your DNA data and open up new avenues for family history exploration.

Choose the Right DNA Test for Your Goals

DNA testing for genealogy comes in various forms, and it's essential to choose the right one based on your research goals. There are three primary types of DNA tests used in genealogy: autosomal DNA, Y-DNA, and mitochondrial DNA. Each offers distinct advantages depending on which ancestral lines you want to investigate.

Key DNA Tests:

• Autosomal DNA: This test analyzes the chromosomes you inherit from both parents. It can help trace ancestry through both your maternal and paternal lines. This test is ideal for exploring the most recent generations (typically 5 to 7 generations back).
• Y-DNA: This test traces the paternal line (father to son) by analyzing the Y chromosome, which is passed down only through males. If you are male and want to focus on your paternal lineage, this test is invaluable.
• Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA): This test traces your maternal line (mother to daughter). It is passed down from mother to child and can be useful for investigating your maternal ancestry.

Selecting the right test depends on whether you are looking to break through brick walls on your paternal line, maternal line, or both. For general genealogical research, autosomal DNA testing is often the most comprehensive choice.

Test with Multiple Companies for More Insights

While one DNA test is a great starting point, testing with multiple DNA testing companies can provide you with more opportunities to break through brick walls. Different companies offer unique databases, algorithms, and match strategies that may help you find different matches or provide more detailed insights.

Why Test with Multiple Companies:

• Different Databases: Each company has its own genetic database, meaning that a match found on one company's platform might not be present on another.
• Better Matching Algorithms: Different companies use different matching algorithms, which could result in finding relatives that you might miss on another platform.
• Expanded Match Pool: By testing with more companies, you significantly increase your chances of finding genealogical matches and connections.

Popular DNA testing companies include AncestryDNA, 23andMe, FamilyTreeDNA, and MyHeritage. Testing with at least two companies can improve your chances of finding crucial matches.

Start with the Close Matches and Work Backwards

When you receive your DNA test results, the first thing you'll notice is the list of genetic matches. These matches will range from close relatives (like siblings or parents) to more distant connections (like 4th cousins or beyond). One of the most effective ways to break through brick walls is to start by working with your close matches and gradually work your way outward.

How to Work with Close Matches:

• Reach Out to Matches: Contact your closest matches and see if they have additional family history information that could help. They may have already researched the same lines and can provide valuable insights.
• Review Family Trees: Often, close matches will have their family trees linked to their DNA results. Compare their family trees with yours to identify any overlapping ancestors.
• Collaborate on Research: Close matches can be great collaborators. They might have access to different records or documents that could help you fill in your family tree.

By working your way from close to distant relatives, you can gradually expand your family tree and identify connections that might have otherwise gone unnoticed.

Use a Genealogy Database to Organize and Cross-Reference Your Results

Once you've received your DNA results, the next step is to organize the information. Genealogy databases and software can help you keep track of your matches, family trees, and other research data in one centralized location. This will allow you to cross-reference DNA matches with traditional genealogical research.

Popular Genealogy Databases and Tools:

• Ancestry.com: This platform allows you to link your DNA results to your family tree and provides various record collections that can help validate your matches.
• MyHeritage : Similar to Ancestry.com, MyHeritage offers DNA testing as well as access to extensive family tree-building tools and record databases.
• FamilySearch: A free platform provided by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, FamilySearch allows you to build and explore family trees.

Using these tools to organize your results will make it easier to identify patterns and spot potential areas for further research, allowing you to break through brick walls more effectively.

Focus on Unknown Parentage with Adoption DNA Research

Adoption can create significant barriers in family history research, particularly when it comes to unknown parentage. DNA testing is a powerful tool for uncovering hidden familial connections in cases of adoption, paternity testing, or other instances of unknown parentage.

Steps for Adoption DNA Research:

• Search for Birth Family Matches: In cases of adoption, your DNA results may reveal matches with biological relatives who can help uncover your birth family and connect you to your heritage.
• Join Adoption Support Groups: Many adoptees have successfully found their birth families by using DNA testing. Joining online groups dedicated to adoption-related genealogy can help you gain insights from others' experiences and provide guidance.
• Contact Close Matches: If your matches are close relatives of your birth parents or biological family members, reaching out to them could provide the key to unlocking your adoption records or family history.

DNA testing provides an avenue for adopted individuals to break through adoption-related brick walls and reconnect with their biological families.

Leverage the Power of Surname Studies and Genetic Projects

In cases where you are stuck on a particular surname or line, one of the most effective ways to break through brick walls is by leveraging surname studies or joining genetic projects. These studies and projects focus on collecting DNA from people with the same surname or ancestry, helping to connect distant relatives and shed light on common ancestors.

Ways to Use Surname Studies:

• Search for a Surname Project: Many surname studies are available through genetic databases like FamilyTreeDNA. These projects gather DNA samples from individuals with the same surname and use the data to identify connections between various branches of the family.
• Join a Genetic Project: Genetic projects focused on particular regions, ethnicities, or family groups can provide powerful insights into your own ancestry. These projects may help connect you with distant relatives and even uncover new familial lines.
• Analyze Y-DNA or mtDNA Results: Surname studies are particularly useful for Y-DNA and mitochondrial DNA research, as these tests focus on specific ancestral lines (paternal or maternal). By comparing your results with others in the project, you may find critical connections.

Surname studies and genetic projects allow you to collaborate with others researching the same ancestral lines and break through research obstacles.

Analyze Historical Records and Genealogical Context

DNA testing is most effective when combined with traditional genealogical research methods, such as examining historical records, census data, and vital records. While DNA testing can uncover genetic connections, historical records can provide the necessary context to validate those connections and make sense of the data.

Combining DNA with Historical Records:

• Verify Family Connections: Once you have identified potential DNA matches, use historical records to verify familial relationships, dates, and locations. This will help you confirm connections and move forward with your research.
• Cross-Reference with Local Histories: Local histories, such as county histories or town records, may provide additional context for your family's place in history and help you validate DNA matches.
• Research Immigration and Naturalization: Many families immigrated from other countries, and naturalization records can provide critical information about their origins. Pairing these records with DNA data can offer deeper insights.

Historical records add depth to your DNA results and help you build a more complete picture of your ancestors.

Be Patient and Persistent

Breaking through a genealogical brick wall can take time and persistence. DNA testing can provide valuable clues, but it often requires patience to sift through results, follow up with matches, and correlate information from multiple sources. The key is to remain focused and keep pushing forward, even when it feels like you've reached a dead end.

Tips for Persistence:

• Review Results Regularly: DNA matches can continue to appear over time as more people test their DNA. Regularly reviewing your results could reveal new connections and insights.
• Stay Organized: Keep detailed notes on all your DNA research, matches, and communications with other genealogists. An organized approach makes it easier to track progress and identify new leads.
• Ask for Help: If you hit a particularly tough brick wall, consider reaching out to professional genealogists or joining online forums where other experienced genealogists can offer advice and assistance.

Genealogical breakthroughs take time. Don't get discouraged by setbacks; instead, stay persistent, and continue exploring every lead.

Use Genetic Genealogy Services and Professional Help

If you've exhausted your personal resources and research methods, it may be time to seek professional help. Genetic genealogists specialize in interpreting DNA results and connecting them to specific ancestral lines. They can offer expert guidance, identify new approaches, and help break through even the most stubborn brick walls.

When to Seek Professional Help:

• Complex Research: If your research is particularly complex or involves multiple brick walls, professional help can save time and provide specialized expertise.
• Interpretation of Results: Sometimes, the results of your DNA tests can be overwhelming. A professional genetic genealogist can help interpret the results in the context of your family history.
• Access to Unique Resources: Professional genealogists often have access to databases and resources that may not be available to the general public.

Professional help can be an investment that accelerates your genealogical progress and helps you break through persistent brick walls.

Stay Open-Minded About Your Results

DNA testing often reveals unexpected results that can change the way you view your family history. You may discover that your ancestry is different than you originally believed, or that you have connections to previously unknown cultures, regions, or relatives. Stay open-minded and embrace these discoveries as part of the journey.

Embracing the Unknown:

• Accept Surprises: Your DNA results may introduce new family lines, ethnicities, or unexpected connections. Rather than feeling disappointed, embrace these discoveries as part of the richness of your family story.
• Adapt Your Research: If your DNA reveals new directions, be willing to adapt your research. Your family history is a dynamic puzzle, and every new piece of information can lead to new avenues of exploration.

By staying open to surprises, you allow yourself to fully embrace the power of DNA testing and its potential to transform your genealogical research.

Conclusion

Using DNA testing to break through brick walls in genealogy is an exciting and powerful approach to uncovering your family's history. By selecting the right test, collaborating with others, leveraging genetic projects, and combining DNA results with traditional research methods, you can expand your family tree and uncover valuable ancestral connections. Stay patient, organized, and open-minded, and your DNA testing may lead to the discovery of hidden branches of your family's past.

View Product