10 Tips for Advanced Interviewing Techniques in Policing

Interviews are a cornerstone of policing, providing law enforcement officers with vital information that can be used to solve cases, gather intelligence, and ensure justice is served. Whether the task is interviewing witnesses, victims, or suspects, the techniques used by officers during these interviews can significantly affect the outcomes of investigations. Advanced interviewing techniques are those that go beyond basic questioning strategies, incorporating psychological insights, behavioral analysis, and cutting-edge methodologies to improve the effectiveness of the interview process.

In this article, we will explore ten advanced interviewing techniques that can enhance the skills of law enforcement officers and improve the quality of their investigations.

Building Rapport: The Cornerstone of Effective Interviews

One of the most essential skills in any interview is the ability to build rapport with the subject. Establishing trust and creating an environment where the individual feels comfortable can lead to more open, honest, and detailed responses. For officers, rapport-building isn't just about being friendly; it's about creating a safe space for the subject to feel heard and understood.

How to build rapport effectively:

• Active Listening: Show genuine interest in what the person is saying. Make eye contact, nod in acknowledgment, and ask follow-up questions that reflect your attentiveness.
• Empathy: Demonstrate understanding of the subject's situation. This is particularly important when interviewing victims or witnesses who may be distressed.
• Neutral Tone: Speak in a neutral and non-judgmental tone. Avoid expressing personal opinions or making any comments that could be perceived as critical or dismissive.
• Non-Verbal Cues: Pay attention to your own body language. An open posture, calm demeanor, and relaxed movements can make the subject feel at ease.

Rapport-building is particularly important when dealing with suspects, as it can encourage cooperation and reduce the chances of resistance or hostile behavior during the interview.

Cognitive Interviewing: Recalling Details Through Cognitive Techniques

Cognitive interviewing is a technique that focuses on enhancing the accuracy and quantity of information recalled by the interviewee. Originally developed for use in witness interviews, it leverages psychological principles to improve the recall process, especially in cases involving memory distortion or lapses. This technique is particularly valuable when interviewing witnesses to traumatic events.

Key components of cognitive interviewing include:

• Context Reinstatement: Encourage the subject to mentally recreate the scene or situation of the event being discussed. Ask them to describe the environment, sounds, smells, and their emotions at the time.
• Open-ended Questions: Rather than leading or closed-ended questions, ask open-ended questions that encourage the subject to elaborate on their memories.
• Report Everything: Instruct the subject to share even the smallest or seemingly insignificant details. This often leads to unexpected breakthroughs in memory recall.
• Change of Perspective: Ask the subject to recall the event from a different perspective, such as how it might have looked from a different vantage point or from the point of view of another person involved.

This technique helps counter the effects of memory decay and false memories, making it particularly useful when investigating older cases or traumatic events.

The Reid Technique: Behavioral Analysis and Interrogation

The Reid Technique is a well-known interrogation method designed to identify deception through the analysis of verbal and non-verbal cues. This approach involves a two-phase process: the interview phase (where the focus is on gathering information) and the interrogation phase (where the goal is to extract a confession, if necessary). Advanced officers should have a solid understanding of how to interpret behavior and apply interrogation techniques to detect deception.

Key elements of the Reid Technique include:

• Behavioral Baseline Establishment: During the initial stages of the interview, officers establish a baseline of the subject's normal behavior, which can then be used to detect deviations that may indicate dishonesty.
• Avoiding Yes/No Questions: Questions that can be answered with a simple "yes" or "no" are avoided. These can allow a deceptive subject to maintain control over the conversation and avoid further questioning.
• Strategic Confrontation: The interrogator confronts the subject with evidence, suggesting their involvement in the crime. This is typically done in a non-accusatory manner, leaving the subject with an opportunity to deny or confess.
• Minimizing the Crime: If the suspect is inclined to confess, minimizing the severity of the crime can help encourage them to speak. For instance, offering excuses for their behavior can reduce their sense of guilt.

Although highly effective, the Reid Technique must be applied carefully, as it can lead to false confessions if not done correctly.

Using the PEACE Model: Ethical Interviewing

The PEACE model is an ethical alternative to the Reid Technique, particularly focused on non-confrontational, non-coercive methods of interviewing. This model is based on the principle that interviews should be conducted in an open, fair, and ethical manner, with the aim of seeking the truth rather than extracting a confession.

The PEACE model consists of five stages:

1. Preparation and Planning: Before the interview, officers should plan the questions, gather background information, and consider the specific objectives of the interview.
2. Engage and Explain: Establish rapport, explain the purpose of the interview, and clarify the rights and responsibilities of the interviewee.
3. Account: Gather the narrative of events from the interviewee, encouraging them to speak freely and at length.
4. Closure: Ensure the subject understands the process, and provide an opportunity for any final comments or clarifications.
5. Evaluate: Assess the information provided to determine its reliability and relevance.

This model places a strong emphasis on fairness and transparency, making it an excellent choice for those looking to avoid unethical interrogation tactics.

The Importance of Non-Verbal Communication

Non-verbal communication, such as body language, facial expressions, and posture, can provide valuable insights into the subject's state of mind during an interview. Advanced officers should be trained to observe these non-verbal cues, as they can indicate emotional responses, discomfort, or signs of deception.

Key non-verbal signals to monitor include:

• Eye Movement: Shifty or evasive eye movement may suggest discomfort or deception, though it is not always a reliable indicator on its own.
• Facial Expressions: Microexpressions---brief, involuntary facial expressions---can reveal underlying emotions such as guilt, anger, or fear.
• Posture: Crossed arms or a closed posture can indicate defensiveness, while open, relaxed body language may suggest a willingness to cooperate.
• Gestures: Excessive or unusual gestures, such as fidgeting or avoiding physical contact, can provide clues to the subject's emotional state.

While non-verbal cues should not be taken in isolation, they can complement verbal communication and provide a fuller picture of the subject's mindset.

The Use of Silence: Strategic Pauses for Reflection

Silence is one of the most powerful tools in an interviewer's arsenal. After a subject responds to a question, maintaining a brief moment of silence can create pressure, compelling the subject to continue speaking or offer additional details. Silence can be particularly useful when interviewing suspects or witnesses who may be hesitant to speak or who are hiding crucial information.

How to use silence effectively:

• Give Time for Thought: After a question, allow the subject time to reflect before responding. This can help them gather their thoughts and provide more accurate information.
• Let the Silence Work: Resist the urge to fill awkward silences with chatter. Let the subject take the lead in conversation.
• Encourage Further Disclosure: A well-timed pause can push the subject to offer more information out of discomfort with the silence.

Silence can often prompt subjects to disclose details they might not have otherwise volunteered, making it a potent tool when used strategically.

Emotional Manipulation: Recognizing and Leveraging Emotions

Emotional manipulation is a technique where the interviewer strategically taps into the subject's emotions to guide the interview in a desired direction. While this tactic must be used with caution and responsibility, it can be effective when used appropriately in situations involving suspects or witnesses.

Some emotions that may be leveraged include:

• Guilt: When interviewing suspects, expressing empathy for their situation and appealing to their conscience may lead them to open up and confess.
• Fear or Anxiety: Witnesses may be reluctant to share crucial information due to fear. Acknowledging their fears and offering reassurances can sometimes ease their concerns and encourage cooperation.
• Sympathy for Victims: When interviewing victims, showing genuine empathy for their distress can foster trust and encourage them to share details they might have been reluctant to reveal.

While emotional manipulation can be a powerful technique, it must be used ethically, ensuring that the interviewee is not coerced into saying anything they do not believe to be true.

The Power of Open-Ended Questions

Open-ended questions are critical to advanced interviewing because they encourage the interviewee to provide more detailed, thoughtful answers. These questions require more than a simple "yes" or "no" response, allowing the subject to elaborate on their thoughts and provide deeper insights into their knowledge of an event.

Examples of open-ended questions include:

• "Can you describe what happened during the incident?"
• "What was your thought process when you made that decision?"
• "Tell me more about what you saw at the scene."

Open-ended questions prompt the subject to provide fuller responses, making it easier for the interviewer to identify inconsistencies or areas that require further clarification.

Establishing a Clear Objective: Focusing on the Purpose of the Interview

Every interview should have a clear, defined objective. Whether the goal is to gather information, obtain a confession, or clarify details, the interviewer must remain focused on this objective throughout the session. It's essential to prepare in advance, plan the questions, and ensure that the conversation stays on track.

Key considerations when defining an interview objective:

• Objective Clarity: Make sure the subject understands why they are being interviewed and the overall objective of the conversation.
• Question Planning: Tailor your questions to align with the primary goal of the interview.
• Adaptability: Be prepared to adjust your strategy based on the responses you receive. If new, relevant information arises during the interview, it may require a shift in your approach.

By maintaining focus and a clear objective, you can improve the effectiveness of the interview and increase the chances of obtaining valuable information.

Continuous Learning and Practice: Refining Interviewing Skills

Advanced interviewing techniques require constant practice and refinement. Officers must be committed to learning and adapting to new methods and psychological insights. Regular training, role-playing exercises, and review of past interviews can help officers continuously improve their interviewing skills.

How to keep refining your interviewing skills:

• Attend Training Sessions: Participate in advanced interviewing and interrogation training to learn new techniques and stay up to date with best practices.
• Peer Reviews: Regularly review your interviews with colleagues to identify areas for improvement.
• Practice: The more interviews you conduct, the better you will become at identifying subtle cues, building rapport, and applying advanced techniques effectively.

By dedicating time to ongoing learning, officers can consistently improve their ability to conduct high-quality interviews, leading to better investigative outcomes and a more professional approach to law enforcement.

Conclusion

Mastering advanced interviewing techniques is essential for law enforcement officers who want to get the best results from their interviews and interrogations. By employing strategies such as building rapport, using cognitive interviewing, recognizing non-verbal cues, and leveraging emotions strategically, officers can enhance their ability to gather accurate information and gain valuable insights into their cases. Continuous learning and ethical practices should always be at the forefront of any interview process, ensuring that the integrity of the investigation is upheld while maximizing its effectiveness.

View Product