Top-Rated Outdoor Fire Pit Heater For Propane vs. Natural Gas: An Actionable Guide

Creating the perfect outdoor space often requires selecting the right fire pit to enhance your yard or patio. Fire pits provide warmth, ambiance, and a space to gather, but choosing between propane and natural gas as fuel options can significantly impact your overall experience. Both options have their benefits and limitations, making it essential to evaluate your needs before making a decision.

This guide will delve into the differences between propane and natural gas fire pit heaters and provide actionable insights into choosing the right one for your space. We'll also highlight top-rated fire pits for both fuel options to help you make an informed purchase.

Propane vs. Natural Gas: What You Need to Know

Before diving into specific models, it's essential to understand the key differences between propane and natural gas as fuel sources for outdoor fire pit heaters. Here's a breakdown of the pros and cons of each option to guide your decision-making process:

1. Propane Fire Pits

Advantages of Propane Fire Pits:

• Portability: Propane fire pits are highly portable because they use small, refillable propane tanks. This makes them an excellent choice for renters or those who like to move their fire pit around to different locations in their yard or on camping trips.
• No Installation Required: One of the most attractive features of propane fire pits is their easy setup. There's no need for a natural gas line installation or complex plumbing. Simply attach the tank, and you're ready to go.
• Quick Setup: Propane fire pits can be used immediately after setup, providing instant warmth and ambiance. This is ideal for spontaneous gatherings or outdoor events where you need heat quickly.
• Intense Heat: Propane burns hotter than natural gas, which means you can get more heat from the same-sized fire pit. This is perfect for colder climates where higher heat output is essential for comfort.

Disadvantages of Propane Fire Pits:

• Ongoing Costs: While propane offers convenience, it comes with recurring costs, as the tanks need to be refilled or replaced regularly. This can add up over time, especially for frequent users.
• Limited Fuel Supply: Propane tanks are limited in size and will need to be replaced or refilled. This may be inconvenient if you are hosting a long outdoor gathering or use your fire pit frequently.
• Environmental Impact: Propane is a fossil fuel, and while it burns cleaner than some other fuels, it still contributes to greenhouse gas emissions.

2. Natural Gas Fire Pits

Advantages of Natural Gas Fire Pits:

• Endless Fuel Supply: The most significant advantage of a natural gas fire pit is the unlimited fuel supply as long as you have a direct connection to the gas line. This means you never have to worry about refilling tanks or running out of fuel during a gathering.
• Lower Operating Costs: In many areas, natural gas is less expensive than propane. Once your fire pit is connected to your home's gas line, the cost of fuel is usually much lower than that of propane, especially over the long term.
• Cleaner Burning: Natural gas is considered cleaner than propane and many other fossil fuels. It produces fewer emissions and is less harmful to the environment, making it a more eco-friendly option for homeowners.
• Consistent Heat: Natural gas fire pits tend to provide more consistent heat, especially for large gatherings. The connection to your home's gas line ensures that you have a steady supply of fuel, so the fire won't die out unexpectedly.

Disadvantages of Natural Gas Fire Pits:

• Installation Costs: The major downside to natural gas fire pits is the need for a gas line connection. This may require professional installation, especially if your outdoor area is not already equipped with a gas line. This can lead to higher upfront costs.
• Less Portability: Unlike propane fire pits, natural gas fire pits are not portable. Once installed, they are fixed to one location. This can be limiting for those who want flexibility in their outdoor setups.
• Longer Setup Time: Setting up a natural gas fire pit can take longer due to the need for a gas line connection and the associated installation process.

Key Considerations for Choosing Between Propane and Natural Gas

When deciding between propane and natural gas for your outdoor fire pit, several factors come into play. Here are some key considerations to help you determine which fuel type is right for you:

1. Outdoor Space and Usage Frequency

• If you use your fire pit occasionally or want the flexibility to move it around, a propane fire pit may be the best choice. Propane offers portability and immediate setup, making it ideal for those who want convenience.
• If you plan to use your fire pit regularly or for extended periods, natural gas may be more cost-effective in the long run. The unlimited fuel supply and lower operating costs make it ideal for frequent use, especially for those with large outdoor spaces or who entertain often.

2. Cost and Installation Considerations

• Upfront Costs: Propane fire pits typically have a lower initial cost since they don't require professional installation or modifications to your home's infrastructure. If you want a budget-friendly, DIY option, propane is the way to go.
• Long-Term Costs: Natural gas, on the other hand, may require higher initial costs for installation but tends to be more affordable in the long run due to lower fuel costs. If you have a permanent outdoor space and want to invest in a long-term solution, natural gas is the more economical choice.

3. Environmental Impact

If environmental sustainability is a priority for you, natural gas is the cleaner option. While both propane and natural gas are fossil fuels, natural gas produces fewer emissions, making it a more eco-friendly choice in the long run.

4. Aesthetic and Functionality

Some fire pits are designed to work exclusively with either propane or natural gas. While both fuel types offer various aesthetic options, be sure to choose a fire pit that matches your aesthetic and functionality needs.

• If you prefer a sleek, modern design that seamlessly integrates into your outdoor space, both propane and natural gas fire pits offer several design options.
• For large, more traditional gatherings, a natural gas fire pit can provide consistent heat for a longer duration, while propane may be better suited for smaller, more intimate spaces.

Top-Rated Fire Pit Heaters for Propane vs. Natural Gas

Let's explore some of the best outdoor fire pit heaters available on the market for both propane and natural gas, so you can make an informed choice based on your specific needs.

Best Propane Fire Pit Heaters

1. TACKLIFE Outdoor Propane Fire Pit

• Fuel Type: Propane
• Material: Steel
• Features: A sleek, modern design with easy ignition and adjustable flame control. It comes with a protective cover, making it a durable and portable option for your outdoor space.
• Why It's Great: The TACKLIFE fire pit is perfect for those who want a propane option that's both functional and stylish. Its portability makes it ideal for smaller spaces or temporary setups.

2. Outland Living 403 Series Fire Pit

• Fuel Type: Propane
• Material: Steel and aluminum
• Features: It offers a large fire bowl, sleek stainless steel design, and adjustable flame control. This unit is designed for easy portability and easy setup, with a 30,000 BTU output.
• Why It's Great: With a low-maintenance design and excellent heat output, the Outland Living 403 Series is an excellent choice for those who want a reliable and portable propane fire pit.

3. Hiland Propane Gas Fire Pit Table

• Fuel Type: Propane
• Material: Stainless steel and tempered glass
• Features: This propane fire pit offers a stylish table design with a built-in propane tank holder, making it convenient and functional for your outdoor space. It also features an easy ignition system and a 40,000 BTU output.
• Why It's Great: Ideal for entertaining, the Hiland fire pit doubles as a functional table and fire pit, making it a space-saving solution for those who want to maximize their outdoor area.

Best Natural Gas Fire Pit Heaters

1. Hearth Products Controls 60" Linear Natural Gas Fire Pit

• Fuel Type: Natural Gas
• Material: Stainless steel and ceramic
• Features: This high-end fire pit offers a sleek linear design with easy ignition and customization options. It's ideal for larger yards and provides consistent heat throughout the evening.
• Why It's Great: If you're looking for a professional-grade fire pit with a modern aesthetic, the Hearth Products Controls fire pit offers superior quality and durability.

2. Blue Rhino Outdoor Natural Gas Fire Pit

• Fuel Type: Natural Gas
• Material: Cast stone
• Features: With a traditional cast stone design, this fire pit offers a 50,000 BTU output and a durable, weather-resistant finish.
• Why It's Great: The Blue Rhino fire pit is perfect for those looking for a classic look combined with modern functionality. Its natural gas compatibility ensures a steady supply of fuel for extended outdoor enjoyment.

3. Tornado 60-Inch Natural Gas Fire Pit

• Fuel Type: Natural Gas
• Material: Cast aluminum
• Features: This large fire pit offers a sleek and modern design with a durable aluminum frame. It also includes a built-in ignition system and a large fire bowl to accommodate larger gatherings.
• Why It's Great: The Tornado fire pit is ideal for larger spaces and families who entertain often, providing ample heat and reliable performance.

Conclusion

When choosing between propane and natural gas for your outdoor fire pit heater, consider factors such as portability, fuel costs, installation requirements, and environmental impact. Propane is ideal for those seeking convenience, portability, and ease of use, while natural gas is better for permanent installations and long-term cost efficiency.

The fire pits we've highlighted here offer great options for both propane and natural gas, ensuring you can find the perfect solution to meet your needs and elevate your outdoor experience. Whether you want the portability of propane or the endless supply of natural gas, these top-rated models will provide warmth and ambiance for years to come.