Researching the Life of Pericles: A Deep Dive

Pericles, the Athenian statesman, orator, and general, stands as a towering figure in the history of ancient Greece. His life, spanning roughly from 495 to 429 BCE, coincided with the zenith of Athenian power and culture, a period often referred to as the Golden Age of Athens. Researching Pericles' life is not merely a biographical exercise; it's an exploration of Athenian democracy, imperial ambitions, the Peloponnesian War, and the intellectual ferment that shaped Western civilization. This essay will provide a comprehensive guide to researching the life of Pericles, delving into the primary and secondary sources, the historiographical challenges, and the key themes that define his legacy.

I. Laying the Foundation: Primary Sources and Their Limitations

Any serious study of Pericles must begin with a careful examination of the available primary sources. These are the texts written during or shortly after Pericles' life, offering direct glimpses into the man and his times. However, it's crucial to recognize the limitations inherent in these sources. Ancient history, unlike modern biography, rarely provides a complete and unbiased portrait. Most primary sources are fragmented, incomplete, and often colored by the author's own biases and agendas.

A. Thucydides: The Peloponnesian War

Undoubtedly, the most important primary source for understanding Pericles is Thucydides' History of the Peloponnesian War. Thucydides, an Athenian general who lived through the war, offers a meticulously detailed account of the conflict between Athens and Sparta. While the war itself began after Pericles' death, Thucydides provides invaluable information about Pericles' leadership, his political philosophy, and his strategic vision for Athens. Critically, Thucydides claims to present Pericles' speeches, although it's generally accepted that these are likely reconstructions based on Thucydides' understanding of Pericles' arguments, rather than verbatim transcripts. Thucydides clearly admired Pericles, presenting him as an intelligent and incorruptible leader. However, he also implicitly criticizes the decisions made by Pericles' successors, suggesting that their policies led to Athens' eventual defeat.

When using Thucydides, consider the following:

• Thucydides' Perspective: Remember that Thucydides was an Athenian aristocrat, and his account reflects his social and political background. His perspective may not fully represent the views of the common Athenian citizen.
• Speech Reconstructions: Be cautious about treating Thucydides' rendition of Pericles' speeches as completely accurate. Analyze them as interpretations of Pericles' ideas, shaped by Thucydides' own intellectual framework.
• The Scope of the History: Thucydides' work focuses primarily on the Peloponnesian War. While he provides crucial context for understanding Pericles, it's essential to supplement his account with other sources to gain a more complete picture of Pericles' life and career.

Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, translated by Rex Warner (Penguin Classics, 1972).

B. Plutarch: Parallel Lives

Plutarch, writing centuries after Pericles' death (c. 46-120 CE), offers a biographical account in his Parallel Lives. Plutarch's aim was not strictly historical accuracy, but rather moral edification. He paired famous Greeks with famous Romans, drawing comparisons between their characters and achievements. Plutarch's biography of Pericles is paired with that of Fabius Maximus, a Roman general known for his cautious strategy. Plutarch's work is a valuable source, but it must be treated with caution due to its distance from the events it describes and its focus on moralizing rather than rigorous historical analysis.

When using Plutarch, consider the following:

• Anachronisms and Errors: Plutarch, writing centuries later, inevitably makes some historical errors and anachronisms. Cross-reference his account with other sources to verify its accuracy.
• Moralizing Agenda: Be aware of Plutarch's tendency to emphasize moral lessons. His portrayal of Pericles is shaped by his desire to present a model of virtuous leadership.
• Use of Anecdotes: Plutarch often relies on anecdotes and stories to illustrate Pericles' character. While these anecdotes can be engaging, they should be critically assessed for their reliability.
• Derivative Source: Plutarch relied on earlier sources, many of which are now lost. While he provides unique details, it's important to recognize that his account is not based on firsthand experience.

Plutarch, Parallel Lives, translated by Bernadotte Perrin (Loeb Classical Library).

C. Aristotle: The Athenian Constitution and Politics

Aristotle, though writing after Pericles' death, provides valuable insights into Athenian political institutions and the evolution of democracy. His Athenian Constitution , discovered in the late 19th century, offers a detailed account of the development of Athenian government, including the reforms associated with Pericles. His Politics provides a philosophical analysis of different forms of government, including democracy, and offers observations on the strengths and weaknesses of the Athenian system. While Aristotle's perspective is philosophical and analytical, rather than purely biographical, his work sheds light on the political context in which Pericles operated.

When using Aristotle, consider the following:

• Philosophical Perspective: Aristotle's primary concern is political theory, not biography. His discussion of Pericles is therefore contextualized within his broader analysis of government.
• The Athenian Constitution: This work focuses primarily on the evolution of Athenian political institutions, not solely on Pericles himself. However, it provides valuable background information about the reforms he implemented.
• Potential Bias: Aristotle, while insightful, held his own political views and was critical of certain aspects of democracy. Be aware of his potential biases when interpreting his account of Athenian politics.

Aristotle, The Athenian Constitution, translated by P.J. Rhodes (Penguin Classics, 1984).

Aristotle, Politics, translated by Benjamin Jowett.

D. Other Primary Sources

Besides Thucydides, Plutarch, and Aristotle, other primary sources offer glimpses into Pericles' life and times, although often indirectly. These include:

• Herodotus: While Herodotus' Histories predate Pericles' prominence, they provide important context for understanding the political and cultural landscape of Greece in the 5th century BCE, particularly the Persian Wars and their impact on Athenian identity.
• Old Comedy: Playwrights like Aristophanes often satirized contemporary political figures, including Pericles. While these comedic depictions are exaggerated and often biased, they can offer insights into Pericles' public image and the criticisms he faced. However, remember the context of satire - the plays exaggerate for comedic effect.
• Inscriptions: Archaeological discoveries, such as inscriptions on stone tablets, can provide valuable information about Athenian laws, decrees, and public works projects undertaken during Pericles' era. These sources often provide concrete evidence to support or challenge claims made in literary texts.
• Xenophon: Though writing later, Xenophon's works touch upon Athenian life and political figures, offering additional perspectives.

The careful collation and comparison of these primary sources is essential for building a nuanced understanding of Pericles' life and times. Recognizing the limitations and biases of each source is equally crucial.

II. Navigating the Secondary Literature: Historiographical Debates and Interpretations

In addition to primary sources, a vast body of secondary literature exists on Pericles. These scholarly works offer interpretations and analyses of the primary sources, providing different perspectives on Pericles' life, his policies, and his legacy. Engaging with the secondary literature is essential for understanding the ongoing historiographical debates surrounding Pericles and for developing your own informed perspective.

A. Key Themes in Periclean Scholarship

Several key themes dominate the scholarly discussion of Pericles:

• The Nature of Athenian Democracy: Was Athenian democracy genuinely democratic, or was it dominated by an elite class? How did Pericles contribute to the development of Athenian democracy, and what were the limitations of his reforms? Some scholars argue that Pericles' policies expanded democratic participation, while others contend that he consolidated power in the hands of the Athenian aristocracy.
• The Athenian Empire: Was the Athenian Empire a benevolent force that brought prosperity and stability to the Greek world, or was it an oppressive regime that exploited its subject states? What was Pericles' role in the expansion and maintenance of the Athenian Empire, and what were the ethical implications of his policies? Some scholars emphasize the benefits that Athenian rule brought to its allies, while others highlight the injustices and exploitation inherent in the imperial system.
• The Causes of the Peloponnesian War: What were the underlying causes of the Peloponnesian War, and what role did Pericles play in triggering the conflict? Was the war inevitable, or could it have been avoided? Some scholars attribute the war to Athenian aggression and imperial ambition, while others emphasize the role of Spartan fear and insecurity.
• Pericles' Leadership: Was Pericles an effective and admirable leader, or was he flawed and ultimately responsible for Athens' misfortunes? How did his personality, his political skills, and his strategic vision shape the course of Athenian history? Scholars debate the extent to which Pericles' leadership was responsible for Athens' success and its ultimate failure.
• The Golden Age of Athens: To what extent was the "Golden Age" of Athens a genuine period of cultural and intellectual flourishing, and to what extent was it a mythologized version of the past? How did Pericles contribute to the cultural achievements of Athens, and what were the social and economic costs of this cultural flowering? Some scholars emphasize the extraordinary achievements of Athenian art, literature, and philosophy during Pericles' era, while others point to the social inequalities and imperial exploitation that underpinned this cultural flowering.

B. Identifying Key Scholars and Works

Numerous scholars have contributed to our understanding of Pericles. Some prominent figures and their influential works include:

• Donald Kagan: Kagan's multi-volume history of the Peloponnesian War provides a comprehensive and detailed account of the conflict, including a thorough analysis of Pericles' role and strategies. His works often offer a balanced and nuanced perspective on Pericles' leadership.
• Victor Ehrenberg: Ehrenberg's biography of Pericles remains a classic study of the statesman's life and times. His work provides a detailed examination of Pericles' political career and his impact on Athenian society.
• Simon Hornblower: Hornblower's commentary on Thucydides provides a detailed analysis of the text, shedding light on Thucydides' perspective and the historical context in which he wrote. His work is essential for understanding the primary source material on Pericles.
• P.J. Rhodes: Rhodes' work on the Athenian Constitution and Athenian democracy offers valuable insights into the political institutions of Athens and the evolution of democratic government. His scholarship helps contextualize Pericles' reforms within the broader development of Athenian democracy.
• Jennifer Roberts: Roberts explores the role of women in Periclean Athens, challenging traditional narratives that focus solely on male citizens and political elites.
• Josiah Ober: Ober's work focuses on the relationship between democracy and social and economic structures in ancient Athens, providing important context for understanding Pericles' policies and their impact on Athenian society.

This is not an exhaustive list, but it provides a starting point for exploring the diverse range of scholarly perspectives on Pericles. Consulting bibliographies and online databases such as JSTOR and Project MUSE can help you discover additional relevant works.

C. Evaluating Secondary Sources

When engaging with secondary literature, it's crucial to evaluate the sources critically. Consider the following:

• The Author's Perspective: What is the author's background, and what are their intellectual and political biases? How might their perspective influence their interpretation of the primary sources?
• The Argument and Evidence: What is the author's main argument, and what evidence do they use to support their claims? Is the evidence convincing, and are there alternative interpretations?
• The Historiographical Context: How does the author's work fit into the broader historiographical debates surrounding Pericles? Are they challenging or reinforcing existing interpretations?
• The Scope and Limitations: What is the scope of the author's study, and what are its limitations? Does the author acknowledge the limitations of their analysis?
• Peer Review: Has the work been peer-reviewed, ensuring that it meets the standards of scholarly rigor? Publications in reputable academic journals and university presses are generally subject to peer review.

III. Key Themes in Pericles' Life and Era

To conduct a thorough and insightful research project, you must understand the key themes interwoven within Pericles' life and the era he dominated.

A. The Development of Athenian Democracy

Pericles is often credited with furthering the development of Athenian democracy. Researching his specific reforms is crucial: jury pay, which enabled poorer citizens to participate in the judicial system, and the increased power of the Assembly (the Ecclesia), where all male citizens could vote and debate. Investigate the extent to which these reforms truly democratized Athenian society. Were they genuine attempts to empower the people, or were they merely tools to consolidate Pericles' own power? What limitations remained on who could participate in the democratic process (e.g., women, slaves, metics)?

B. The Athenian Empire and Imperialism

Pericles oversaw the expansion and consolidation of the Athenian Empire, a powerful maritime force that dominated the Aegean Sea. Research the Delian League, originally formed to defend against Persia, and its transformation into an Athenian empire under Pericles. Analyze the economic benefits Athens derived from its empire (tribute, trade) and the impact on its subject states. Explore the moral and ethical implications of Athenian imperialism. Was it a just and benevolent system, or was it based on exploitation and oppression? Understanding the empire is key to understanding Pericles' power base and the resources he had available to implement his policies.

C. The Peloponnesian War

Although Pericles died early in the Peloponnesian War, his policies and strategic vision shaped the early stages of the conflict. Research his strategy of avoiding land battles against Sparta and relying on Athens' naval power. Analyze the strengths and weaknesses of this strategy and its ultimate impact on the war. Explore the debates surrounding Pericles' responsibility for the war. Was the war inevitable given the tensions between Athens and Sparta, or could Pericles have pursued a more peaceful course?

D. Athenian Culture and the Arts

Pericles' era is often referred to as the Golden Age of Athens, a period of unprecedented cultural and artistic achievement. Research the major architectural projects undertaken during his rule, such as the Parthenon and other buildings on the Acropolis. Explore the contributions of prominent artists, writers, and philosophers who flourished during this period, such as Phidias, Sophocles, and Anaxagoras. Analyze the relationship between Athenian democracy and cultural innovation. Did Athenian democracy foster creativity and intellectual inquiry, or did it create a climate of political instability and social unrest?

E. Pericles' Personal Life and Character

While the primary sources provide limited information about Pericles' personal life, it's important to explore what is known about his family, his relationships, and his personality. Research his relationship with Aspasia, a highly educated woman who exerted considerable influence on Athenian intellectual life. Analyze the criticisms leveled against Pericles by his political opponents, such as Cleon. Consider the impact of his personal experiences on his political decisions.

IV. Methodological Considerations for Research

Effective research requires a systematic and rigorous approach. Consider the following methodological considerations:

A. Formulating a Research Question

Begin by formulating a clear and focused research question. For example, instead of simply asking "What was Pericles' role in Athenian history?", you might ask "To what extent did Pericles' policies contribute to the development of Athenian democracy, and what were the limitations of his democratic reforms?" A well-defined research question will guide your research and help you stay focused.

B. Developing a Research Strategy

Develop a comprehensive research strategy that outlines the steps you will take to answer your research question. This should include identifying relevant primary and secondary sources, planning your reading schedule, and determining how you will organize and analyze your data.

C. Analyzing Primary Sources Critically

As discussed earlier, primary sources must be analyzed critically. Consider the author's perspective, the historical context, and the potential biases of the source. Cross-reference information from different primary sources to verify its accuracy.

D. Engaging with Secondary Literature

Engage with the secondary literature to understand the existing scholarly debates surrounding Pericles. Identify key scholars and their influential works. Evaluate secondary sources critically, considering the author's perspective, the argument and evidence, and the historiographical context.

E. Synthesizing Information and Drawing Conclusions

Synthesize information from primary and secondary sources to develop your own informed perspective on Pericles. Support your arguments with evidence from the sources. Acknowledge the limitations of your analysis and consider alternative interpretations.

F. Avoiding Plagiarism

Plagiarism is a serious academic offense. Always cite your sources properly and give credit to the authors whose work you have used. Use quotation marks to indicate direct quotes and paraphrase carefully, ensuring that you are not simply copying the language of others.

V. Concluding Thoughts: Pericles' Enduring Legacy

Researching the life of Pericles is a rewarding but challenging endeavor. It requires careful analysis of primary sources, engagement with secondary literature, and a nuanced understanding of the historical context. By adopting a systematic and rigorous approach, you can gain valuable insights into Pericles' life, his policies, and his enduring legacy. His impact on Athenian democracy, his leadership during the Peloponnesian War, and his contributions to Athenian culture continue to be debated and reinterpreted by historians today. Pericles remains a complex and fascinating figure whose life offers valuable lessons about leadership, democracy, and the challenges of empire. He serves as a powerful reminder that the study of ancient history can provide insights into the present and help us grapple with the enduring questions of human existence.

View Product