How to Understand the Stoic View on Wealth

Wealth has been a subject of deep contemplation across many schools of thought. While modern societies often link wealth with success, happiness, and a high status, the Stoic philosophy offers a unique perspective on wealth. The Stoics, with their emphasis on virtue, reason, and the pursuit of inner peace, present a countercultural viewpoint that challenges the traditional view of wealth as a symbol of happiness. In this article, we will delve into the Stoic view on wealth, its underlying principles, and how it contrasts with the way wealth is typically understood in modern society.

The Core Stoic Beliefs

Before understanding the Stoic perspective on wealth, it's essential to grasp the foundational principles of Stoicism itself. Stoicism, founded by Zeno of Citium in the early 3rd century BCE, emphasizes virtue as the highest good. According to the Stoics, everything outside of one's own character and virtue is indifferent. They believed that external events, including wealth, poverty, health, and status, are neither good nor bad in themselves; instead, it is our reaction to them that determines their value.

Stoics distinguish between things that are in our control and those that are not. The only thing truly within our control is our own behavior and judgments. Everything else---wealth, health, fame, and even relationships---are external factors that do not inherently determine our happiness. The Stoic goal, therefore, is to live a life aligned with virtue, guided by wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance, irrespective of the external circumstances.

The Stoic View of Wealth

Wealth, in the eyes of Stoics, falls into the category of "externals" or "indifferents." This means that wealth is neither good nor bad in itself. It's what we do with it, how we regard it, and how it affects our character that makes the difference.

Wealth as an External

For the Stoic, wealth is classified as an "external" good. External goods refer to things that can influence our lives but do not inherently shape our moral character. According to Epictetus, one of the most famous Stoic philosophers, wealth does not have intrinsic value; rather, it is simply something that can be used, or misused, depending on our judgment and how we handle it.

The Stoic perspective is not that wealth is bad or to be shunned, but that it should be used with caution and not sought after as an end in itself. It's a tool that can be employed for practical purposes, but its pursuit should not dominate one's life.

The Dichotomy of Control

One of the most powerful ideas in Stoicism is the dichotomy of control. This principle teaches that there are things we can control (our thoughts, beliefs, attitudes, and actions) and things we cannot control (external events, other people's actions, the past, the future). Wealth, like all external factors, falls into the category of things we cannot control.

While we can control how we respond to wealth---whether we become obsessed with accumulating it or whether we use it for virtuous purposes---we cannot control the amount of wealth we accumulate. A Stoic would advise us not to base our sense of self-worth or happiness on wealth, because its presence or absence is not something we fully control.

Wealth and Virtue

For Stoics, the pursuit of virtue should always be the highest priority. Wealth, when attained, can be used to further one's virtuous goals. However, the key is not to be attached to it. A Stoic would ask themselves: how can this wealth serve my pursuit of virtue? Is it helping me grow in wisdom, temperance, justice, or courage? If not, then it is not worth prioritizing.

Seneca, a Stoic philosopher and statesman, emphasized this point in his letters, where he often discusses how wealth can be a hindrance to virtue when it is sought for its own sake or used for indulgence. He notes that wealth can promote arrogance, greed, and excessive desire, all of which are obstacles to living a virtuous life. In his essay On the Shortness of Life, Seneca points out that many people waste their time and energy chasing wealth, only to find that it brings them neither happiness nor fulfillment in the end.

Thus, Stoics would argue that wealth is not inherently bad, but that it should not be sought for the wrong reasons. Instead, it should be viewed as something that can either aid or distract from the path to virtue.

The Stoic Practice of Detachment

Detachment is another central Stoic practice, especially when it comes to external possessions like wealth. While Stoics don't advocate for a life of extreme asceticism, they do encourage individuals to remain detached from the outcomes of their material pursuits.

Detachment in the Stoic sense means not allowing one's happiness or well-being to depend on wealth. Instead, wealth should be treated as a temporary, neutral external circumstance. For instance, Marcus Aurelius, the Roman emperor and Stoic philosopher, frequently reminded himself in his Meditations that life is fleeting and that all external things, including wealth, are ultimately unimportant in comparison to the pursuit of wisdom.

The Negative Role of Attachment

The Stoic view on wealth calls attention to the negative consequences of becoming attached to material possessions. Wealth can be addictive; it can become a source of pride, envy, and competition. A person who is excessively attached to wealth may find themselves enslaved by their desire for more. This desire can cloud their judgment and take away their inner peace, something that is contrary to Stoic teachings.

When one becomes too attached to wealth, they may experience anxiety about losing it or fear of never acquiring enough. This constant worry is antithetical to the Stoic ideal of tranquility. Therefore, Stoics recommend cultivating an attitude of detachment---viewing wealth as something that can come and go without affecting one's emotional stability.

The Virtue of Self-Control

In Stoicism, self-control or temperance is a central virtue. Wealth, when used with moderation and wisdom, can be a tool for living a virtuous life. However, if wealth is pursued excessively or used in indulgent ways, it can lead to the opposite of virtue: excess, greed, and indulgence.

Stoics emphasize living in accordance with nature, which includes moderating one's desires. A person who is excessively attached to wealth is failing to live in accordance with nature, as they are allowing their desires for external goods to override their reason and sense of balance.

In this sense, self-control over the pursuit and use of wealth is not just a matter of ethics but of personal happiness. True happiness, according to the Stoics, is achieved not through wealth, but through living a life guided by virtue and reason.

Practical Stoic Advice on Wealth

So, how can we apply Stoic principles to our own relationship with wealth? Here are some practical guidelines based on Stoic teachings:

1. Seek Virtue, Not Wealth

According to Stoicism, the pursuit of virtue should always take precedence over the pursuit of wealth. If you focus on living a virtuous life---acting with wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance---wealth will be secondary. It may come or it may not, but it will not define your happiness.

2. Use Wealth as a Tool, Not an End Goal

Wealth can be a useful tool for living a good life, but it is not the goal. For example, wealth can provide you with the resources to care for your family, help others, or pursue personal growth. But it should never become your primary focus.

3. Practice Detachment

Cultivate detachment from your possessions. While you may enjoy material comforts, remember that they are temporary. Don't allow your sense of identity or well-being to depend on them. If you lose your wealth, remind yourself that it does not take away your value as a person.

4. Focus on the Present

Wealth often causes people to focus on the future, constantly chasing more and fearing what might happen if they don't accumulate enough. The Stoic approach encourages focusing on the present moment and accepting whatever comes, without excessive worry or desire for future wealth.

5. Embrace Contentment

Finally, cultivate contentment with what you have. Stoics are not against having wealth, but they are against needing it to feel fulfilled. Contentment comes from within, from aligning your life with virtue, not from the accumulation of external goods.

Conclusion

The Stoic view of wealth is profound and challenges much of modern society's conventional thinking. Stoics do not deny the utility of wealth, but they emphasize that wealth should never be an end in itself. Instead, it should be seen as a tool that can support a virtuous life but should not dictate our happiness or sense of self-worth. By practicing detachment, moderation, and virtue, we can cultivate a healthy relationship with wealth---one that leads to inner peace and true happiness, rather than anxiety, greed, or excessive desire. Through this lens, wealth is not the problem, but our attachment to it is. And it is this wisdom that can help us navigate the complexities of wealth in our own lives.

View Product