How To Understand the Privacy Risks of Smart Toys

The rise of the Internet of Things (IoT) has brought about a new generation of devices that connect to the internet and can interact with users in various ways. Among these devices, smart toys have become increasingly popular, especially in homes with young children. These toys are designed to be interactive, engaging, and educational, offering a unique way for children to learn and play. However, as these toys become more advanced, there are growing concerns about the privacy risks they pose, both to children and their families. In this article, we will explore the privacy risks associated with smart toys, how they work, and what can be done to mitigate these risks.

What Are Smart Toys?

Smart toys are toys that are connected to the internet or capable of communicating with other devices through Bluetooth or Wi-Fi. These toys can range from simple gadgets like interactive dolls or robots to more complex devices that offer personalized interactions, track children's progress, and even collect data about their behavior. Some smart toys are designed to engage children through voice commands, facial recognition, or other sensory inputs, while others use artificial intelligence (AI) to adapt to a child's learning style or preferences.

Examples of smart toys include interactive dolls that can talk back to children, robot toys that can be programmed or controlled via a smartphone app, and augmented reality (AR) toys that blend the physical and digital worlds. These toys are often marketed as educational tools, helping children develop skills such as problem-solving, creativity, and social interaction.

How Smart Toys Collect and Use Data

The appeal of smart toys lies in their ability to provide personalized and dynamic experiences for children. To achieve this, many smart toys collect data about a child's interactions, preferences, and behavior. This data can include:

• Voice recordings: Many smart toys, particularly those with voice recognition or interactive features, record children's voices to enable communication. These toys may listen to conversations, requests, or questions, and use this data to provide appropriate responses or learn from the interactions.
• Location data: Some smart toys are equipped with GPS or Bluetooth capabilities, allowing them to track a child's location. This can be useful for certain games or features, such as geolocation-based tasks or safety monitoring.
• Behavioral data: Smart toys may track a child's actions, movements, or preferences during play. For example, an interactive robot might monitor how often a child engages with certain activities or games and use this information to adjust its behavior.
• Facial recognition: Some advanced smart toys use cameras to recognize children's faces, which can allow the toy to personalize its interactions based on the child's identity or mood.
• Personal information: Many smart toys require parents to create accounts or input personal information, such as names, ages, or email addresses, to access certain features or track progress.

While this data can help make the toy more interactive and educational, it also raises concerns about privacy and security. In many cases, the data collected by smart toys can be shared with third parties, including manufacturers, advertisers, and developers of companion apps.

Privacy Risks Associated with Smart Toys

As with any connected device, smart toys introduce a range of privacy risks that can have serious implications for children and their families. These risks stem from the collection, storage, and potential misuse of personal data, as well as the vulnerabilities that can be exploited by hackers or malicious actors.

1. Data Security and Hacking Risks

One of the primary concerns with smart toys is the security of the data they collect. Many of these toys are connected to the internet, which makes them susceptible to hacking. If a toy's security is compromised, hackers could gain access to sensitive data, such as voice recordings, location information, or personal details. In some cases, hackers could also take control of the toy itself, potentially using it to spy on children or gather further data.

For example, in 2017, a smart doll called "My Friend Cayla" was found to have significant security vulnerabilities. The doll, which was marketed as a talking companion for children, could be hacked to listen in on conversations, posing a serious privacy threat. The toy's connection to the internet made it possible for unauthorized parties to eavesdrop on private conversations, which raised concerns about how data collected by smart toys is protected.

2. Unintended Data Sharing with Third Parties

Many smart toys collect data that is shared with third parties, including toy manufacturers, app developers, and advertisers. This data may be used to improve the functionality of the toy, but it can also be monetized in ways that are not always transparent to parents or guardians.

For instance, companies might use the data collected by smart toys to create targeted ads or profile children based on their behaviors and preferences. This practice is particularly concerning because children may not fully understand the concept of advertising, and parents may not realize that their child's interactions with a toy are being used for marketing purposes. In some cases, smart toys may even share data with social media platforms or other online services, raising further privacy concerns.

3. Invasion of Children's Privacy

Children are particularly vulnerable when it comes to privacy risks. They may not fully understand the implications of sharing personal information, such as their name, age, or location, with a connected toy. Smart toys that record children's voices or use cameras to capture images or videos introduce an additional layer of privacy risks. Children may unwittingly share sensitive information, which could be used against them or exploited by malicious actors.

Moreover, the constant collection of data from children's interactions with smart toys could lead to the creation of detailed digital profiles. These profiles could potentially be used for purposes such as behavioral analysis, marketing, or even surveillance. The long-term implications of this kind of data collection on children's privacy and development are still unclear, but they raise significant ethical concerns.

4. Lack of Parental Control and Awareness

In many cases, parents may not be fully aware of the data collection practices associated with smart toys. While manufacturers often provide privacy policies, these documents can be complex and difficult to understand, making it hard for parents to determine what data is being collected and how it will be used. Additionally, many smart toys lack robust parental controls, making it challenging for parents to limit the data collection or prevent the toy from accessing certain features.

Some smart toys also require children to interact with companion apps or online platforms, which may have their own privacy risks. If these apps or platforms are not adequately secured or monitored, they could expose children to further privacy threats, such as unauthorized data sharing or inappropriate content.

5. Ethical Concerns Around Surveillance and Consent

There are also ethical concerns about the extent to which smart toys are used to surveil children. Some toys are designed to track a child's activities or monitor their interactions, which raises questions about consent. Children may not have the capacity to understand or consent to the data collection that takes place, and parents may not fully grasp the extent of the surveillance either.

This surveillance could extend beyond the home environment, with toys potentially tracking children's locations or interactions in public spaces. Such data could be used to build detailed profiles of children's behaviors, preferences, and routines, potentially compromising their privacy in the long term.

Steps to Protect Privacy When Using Smart Toys

While the privacy risks associated with smart toys are significant, there are several steps that parents and guardians can take to mitigate these risks and protect their children's privacy.

1. Research Before Purchasing

Before purchasing a smart toy, it's important to research the product and its data practices. Look for information about how the toy collects and stores data, who has access to that data, and whether the toy has been subject to any security audits. Many toy manufacturers provide privacy policies that outline these details, so be sure to read these documents carefully.

Additionally, check whether the toy offers any parental controls or settings that allow you to manage data collection and sharing. Some toys allow parents to disable certain features, such as voice recording or location tracking, which can help minimize privacy risks.

2. Limit Data Collection and Sharing

Whenever possible, limit the amount of personal data shared with smart toys. For example, avoid inputting sensitive information, such as a child's full name or address, into the toy's companion app or website. You can also disable features that track your child's location or record their voice.

Many smart toys also offer the option to turn off certain features, such as cameras or microphones, which can help reduce the risk of unauthorized surveillance. If a toy doesn't provide adequate privacy controls, consider whether it's worth using in the first place.

3. Regularly Update Software and Firmware

Keeping the software and firmware of smart toys up to date is crucial for maintaining their security. Manufacturers often release updates to fix security vulnerabilities or improve data protection, so be sure to check for updates regularly and install them as soon as they become available. This can help protect against hacking attempts and ensure that your child's data is kept secure.

4. Monitor Interactions with Smart Toys

Supervising your child's interactions with smart toys is another way to mitigate privacy risks. Ensure that your child understands the potential risks of interacting with connected devices and teach them about privacy and data protection. For example, explain why they should avoid sharing personal information, such as their name, age, or location, with the toy.

By monitoring how your child uses the toy, you can also identify any potential privacy issues early on and take action to address them.

5. Consider Alternatives

If you are concerned about the privacy risks associated with smart toys, consider opting for traditional, non-connected toys instead. While these toys may lack the interactive features of smart toys, they still provide opportunities for creative play and learning without the privacy risks. Additionally, non-connected toys don't rely on the internet, which means they are less vulnerable to hacking or data breaches.

Conclusion

Smart toys offer exciting opportunities for children to engage with technology in new and innovative ways. However, as these toys become more advanced, they also introduce significant privacy risks. The collection of sensitive data, the potential for hacking, and the lack of transparency in data practices all pose serious concerns for parents and guardians.

By staying informed about the privacy risks associated with smart toys and taking steps to protect your child's data, you can help ensure that their interactions with these devices remain safe and secure. Whether through limiting data collection, regularly updating security settings, or considering alternative toys, there are practical steps that can be taken to mitigate privacy risks and protect children's digital privacy in an increasingly connected world.

View Product