How to Protect Your Credit Score When Closing Cards

A strong credit score is essential for many aspects of life, including obtaining favorable loan terms, securing low interest rates on credit cards, and even renting an apartment. However, there are occasions when you may want or need to close a credit card account, whether it's due to fees, changing financial goals, or the desire to simplify your financial life. While closing a credit card may seem like a simple process, it can have a significant impact on your credit score if not done carefully.

This article provides a detailed, in-depth guide on how to protect your credit score when closing cards, covering the steps you should take before, during, and after the closure process. We will explore the factors that influence your credit score, potential risks of closing credit cards, and the best strategies for minimizing negative impacts.

Understanding Your Credit Score

Before diving into the process of closing credit cards, it's crucial to understand how your credit score works. Your credit score is a numerical representation of your creditworthiness, which lenders use to assess the risk of lending money to you. The most widely used credit scoring model is FICO, which considers five key factors:

1. Payment History (35%): Your history of making on-time payments on credit accounts, including credit cards, loans, and mortgages.
2. Credit Utilization (30%): The ratio of your current credit card balances to your total available credit limit. A lower utilization ratio is better for your score.
3. Length of Credit History (15%): The average age of your credit accounts, including the oldest account and the newest.
4. Credit Mix (10%): The variety of credit accounts you have, including credit cards, installment loans, and mortgages.
5. New Credit (10%): The number of recent credit inquiries and newly opened accounts. Too many inquiries in a short period can hurt your score.

When you close a credit card account, the changes can affect several of these factors, especially credit utilization, the length of your credit history, and your credit mix. Understanding these components will help you navigate the process and minimize any potential negative effects.

Why Closing Credit Cards Can Impact Your Credit Score

1. Credit Utilization Ratio

One of the most significant factors affected by closing a credit card is your credit utilization ratio. Credit utilization is calculated by dividing your total credit card balances by your total available credit limit. If you close a card, you reduce your available credit, which can increase your utilization ratio if your balances remain the same. A higher utilization ratio can negatively impact your credit score because it signals to lenders that you are using a larger portion of your available credit, which may indicate financial distress.

For example, if you have two credit cards with limits of $5,000 each, your total available credit is $10,000. If you have a balance of $2,000, your utilization rate is 20%. However, if you close one of the cards, your available credit decreases to $5,000, and your utilization ratio rises to 40%, which could hurt your score.

2. Length of Credit History

The length of your credit history plays a role in determining your credit score. When you close a credit card, the account is no longer active, but it remains on your credit report for up to 10 years. However, the closure can shorten the overall age of your credit accounts, especially if the card you are closing is one of your oldest accounts. A shorter average credit history can lower your score, as it may signal a lack of experience in managing credit.

For example, if you've had a credit card for 15 years and another for 5 years, closing the older card will reduce the average age of your accounts, which can negatively affect your score.

3. Credit Mix

Closing a credit card could also affect your credit mix, which is the variety of credit types you have. Credit mix makes up 10% of your credit score, and it is better for your score to have a diverse mix of credit accounts. If your credit card is one of the few types of credit you have (e.g., you have a mortgage but only one or two credit cards), closing it may harm your credit mix and potentially hurt your score.

4. Impact of Hard Inquiries

When you apply for a new credit card or loan, the lender usually conducts a hard inquiry on your credit report. A hard inquiry can temporarily lower your credit score by a few points. While closing a card doesn't involve a hard inquiry, if you decide to open a new card to replace the one you're closing, the hard inquiry may further lower your score in the short term.

Steps to Take Before Closing a Credit Card

To protect your credit score when closing a credit card, there are several preparatory steps you should take. These steps can help you mitigate potential risks and ensure that the closure process is as smooth as possible.

1. Review Your Credit Report

Before closing any credit account, it's essential to review your credit report to understand the impact of the closure. You can access your credit report for free once a year from the three major credit bureaus---Experian, TransUnion, and Equifax---through the website AnnualCreditReport.com. Look for the following:

• Credit Utilization: Check your current utilization ratio on each card.
• Credit History: Identify which card is your oldest account and which accounts have the longest average age.
• Credit Mix: Ensure you have a diverse range of credit accounts (credit cards, loans, mortgages).

This information will help you decide if closing a specific card is worth the potential impact on your credit score.

2. Pay Down Balances

If you have balances on the card you plan to close, it's a good idea to pay them down before closing the account. By doing so, you reduce your overall debt load and lower the chance of a high credit utilization ratio. It's also wise to pay down balances on your other credit cards to maintain a healthy credit utilization rate after the closure.

For instance, if you have multiple cards with balances, consider paying off or transferring balances to cards with higher credit limits to minimize any increase in your utilization ratio.

3. Consider the Timing

Consider the timing of closing your credit card. If you're planning to apply for a major loan, such as a mortgage or car loan, it might be better to delay closing the card until after you've secured the loan. Lenders typically pull your credit report during the application process, and you want to avoid any negative impact on your credit score during this time.

Additionally, if your credit score is already in a good range, closing a card may not significantly affect your ability to secure loans or favorable credit terms. If your score is on the lower end, it may be wise to avoid closing cards until your score has improved.

4. Contact Your Credit Card Issuer

Before officially closing your account, contact your credit card issuer to discuss the process. Some credit card issuers may offer to reduce fees or offer you a different type of card if you're closing your account due to dissatisfaction. If you close your card and later decide to reopen it, some issuers may not allow you to recover the same account, which could negatively affect your credit history.

How to Close a Credit Card Without Hurting Your Credit Score

Once you've taken the necessary steps to prepare for closing a credit card, here's how to close it in a way that minimizes any negative effects on your credit score.

1. Don't Close Old Cards with Long History

If possible, avoid closing your oldest credit card or one with a long history, as it can shorten the length of your credit history. If you must close an older account, ensure that you have other accounts with sufficient history to keep your average credit age reasonable.

2. Keep Other Credit Cards Active

If you have multiple credit cards, consider keeping your other cards active to help maintain your credit utilization ratio and your credit mix. You can use them occasionally for small purchases and then pay off the balance in full each month to keep the accounts in good standing. This will help you maintain a low utilization rate and a healthy credit history.

3. Pay Off the Balance and Avoid Carrying a Balance

Before closing the account, ensure the card has a zero balance. If you leave a balance on the card, it could negatively impact your credit score, especially if you close the account and the card issuer reports the balance to the credit bureaus. Carrying a balance after closing a card can also result in interest charges and fees.

4. Request a Written Confirmation

Once the account is closed, request written confirmation from the card issuer that the account has been closed. This will help ensure there are no misunderstandings and that the account is properly marked as closed on your credit report. This step also provides documentation in case there are any issues in the future.

After Closing a Credit Card: What to Do

After closing a credit card, there are a few additional steps you can take to ensure your credit score remains protected.

1. Monitor Your Credit Report

After closing a credit card, it's important to regularly monitor your credit report to ensure the account is reported correctly. Any discrepancies or errors, such as a reported balance on a closed account, should be disputed with the credit bureau to avoid damage to your score.

2. Avoid Opening New Cards Too Quickly

If you decide to open a new credit card to compensate for the one you closed, be mindful of the hard inquiry that comes with the application. While opening new accounts can help restore your available credit, it can also result in a temporary drop in your score due to the hard inquiry. Limit the frequency of new applications to avoid further damage to your score.

3. Keep Track of Your Credit Utilization

After closing a credit card, keep a close eye on your credit utilization ratio. If your available credit has decreased, it's especially important to keep your balances low to maintain a favorable ratio. Ideally, aim to keep your utilization below 30% to avoid negative impacts on your score.

Conclusion

Closing a credit card can be a strategic move, but it's essential to understand the potential impact on your credit score and take steps to protect it. By carefully considering the timing, the card you close, and your credit utilization, you can minimize the negative effects. With proper planning, it's possible to close a credit card account without causing significant damage to your credit score. Always monitor your credit regularly to ensure that your score stays healthy, and consider reaching out to your card issuer if you have any concerns during the process. With these strategies in place, you can navigate the closure of credit cards while maintaining your financial health.

View Product