How To Master Subtext and Implied Meaning

When we consume art, literature, or media, there's often a deeper layer beneath the surface. It's the part of the narrative that exists in the spaces between the words, the actions, and the silence. This underlying layer is called subtext, and it plays a vital role in how we interpret and connect with a story or piece of work. Subtext can turn an ordinary narrative into something profound and multifaceted, giving the audience a deeper experience without explicitly stating every detail. In this article, we'll explore the concept of subtext, how it is used in various forms of communication, and how you can master the art of creating and interpreting implied meaning.

What is Subtext?

Subtext is the hidden or underlying meaning in a piece of communication, whether it's written, spoken, or visual. It's what is implied but not directly stated. In the context of literature, film, and theatre, subtext operates beneath the surface of the dialogue and actions, influencing how we understand the true motivations, feelings, or circumstances of a character or narrative.

The Role of Subtext in Storytelling

In storytelling, subtext often operates as a form of emotional and intellectual communication between the author, the characters, and the audience. It can express complex emotions, themes, and ideas without having to articulate them plainly. Subtext allows the audience to form their own interpretations, often making the experience more personal and nuanced.

For example, in a conversation between two characters, one might say something like, "It's fine, really. I'm not upset." On the surface, this seems like a straightforward statement, but the subtext may suggest that the speaker is, in fact, deeply upset and trying to hide their true feelings. The power of subtext lies in what is unsaid, in the gaps in communication.

The Difference Between Subtext and Literal Meaning

Subtext should not be confused with literal meaning. The literal meaning refers to the surface-level or explicit content of communication---the words spoken, the actions performed, or the events that occur. Subtext, on the other hand, speaks to the emotions, motivations, and unspoken truths that lie beneath the surface.

To clarify, consider the following example from the movie The Godfather:

• Literal meaning: Michael Corleone tells his wife, "It's over, Kay. It's done."
• Subtext: What Michael is really conveying, through his tone and his unspoken actions, is that the world of crime he has become a part of has consumed him and changed his identity. The statement isn't just about ending something; it's about his personal transformation and the irrevocable choices he's made.

Why Subtext Matters

Subtext adds depth, complexity, and richness to communication. In storytelling, it helps to convey the unspeakable---the things that can't or won't be expressed directly. Subtext engages the audience, encouraging them to actively participate in the interpretation of a story, and allows for multiple layers of meaning.

Here are a few reasons why subtext is important:

• Emotional depth: Subtext allows characters to feel more human and multi-dimensional. A character who only expresses themselves directly can feel one-dimensional, while one who has subtext creates more complex emotional layers that invite empathy from the audience.
• Improved realism: In real life, people rarely say exactly what they mean. Subtext mirrors this truth, reflecting the complexities and contradictions of human communication.
• Tension and drama: Subtext can build tension by making the audience aware of hidden motives, desires, or conflicts. This creates a sense of anticipation, as the audience knows something that the characters may not.
• Intellectual engagement: When used well, subtext requires the audience to think critically and pay attention to the smallest details, making the overall experience more engaging and intellectually stimulating.

How Subtext Works in Different Mediums

1. Literature

In literature, subtext is often woven into the dialogue, narration, and actions of characters. Writers can create subtext through symbolism, irony, character behavior, and even through the words left unspoken. A famous example is F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby. The novel is about the American Dream, wealth, love, and loss, but much of the deeper meaning comes from what is left unsaid between the characters and in the descriptions of setting, particularly with the symbolism of the green light across the bay.

2. Film and Television

In film and television, subtext is conveyed not only through dialogue but also through cinematography, body language, and visual cues. A character's facial expression, the use of lighting, or even the way a scene is framed can all suggest unspoken truths. A scene might show two characters sitting together in silence, but the audience can feel the tension in their body language or the way the camera lingers on them.

For example, in Alfred Hitchcock's Rear Window, the protagonist, Jeff, watches his neighbors through his apartment window. The literal action is him observing others, but the subtext explores deeper themes of voyeurism, isolation, and the ethics of observation.

3. Theatre

In theatre, subtext is often conveyed through performance. Actors use body language, tone, pauses, and pacing to suggest meaning beyond the lines of dialogue. The subtext in theatre can also come from the physical space between characters---how close or distant they are can indicate intimacy, conflict, or power dynamics without needing to say a word.

4. Visual Art

In visual art, subtext is often conveyed through symbolism and imagery. An artist may not explicitly state the meaning of their work, but through their choice of color, composition, and symbols, they can communicate deeper ideas. For instance, in a painting depicting a person standing under a stormy sky, the subtext may suggest internal conflict, danger, or foreshadowing of a tragedy, even though the figure is simply standing still.

5. Poetry

Poetry is perhaps one of the most concentrated forms of subtext. Poets use metaphor, symbolism, and allusion to convey ideas that are not directly stated. The subtext in poetry often demands the reader to dig deeper into the language and form, making the experience more rewarding for those who seek it.

6. Music

In music, subtext can emerge from the contrast between the lyrics and the music itself. A cheerful melody paired with somber lyrics creates a poignant subtext, suggesting a disconnect between outward appearances and internal emotions. Music, especially instrumental pieces, can also communicate subtext through tempo, dynamics, and harmony, evoking specific moods or themes.

Techniques to Master Subtext

Mastering subtext requires attention to nuance, subtlety, and timing. Whether you are writing, acting, or creating art, the following techniques can help you master the art of subtext:

1. Use of Silence

Silence is a powerful tool for creating subtext. What's left unsaid often speaks louder than words. In conversations or scenes, pauses and silences can convey discomfort, tension, or contemplation. Silence allows the audience to fill in the gaps, creating a sense of mystery and intrigue.

2. Nonverbal Communication

A character's body language, facial expressions, and gestures are all vehicles for subtext. Sometimes, what a character doesn't say or how they react physically speaks volumes. For instance, a person may say they are fine, but their crossed arms, averted gaze, or clenched fists could reveal something entirely different.

3. Contradictions

Introducing contradictions into dialogue or actions creates effective subtext. A character may say one thing but do another, creating a discrepancy between their words and actions. This contrast reveals hidden motivations, fears, or desires, encouraging the audience to look deeper into the character's psyche.

4. Symbolism and Metaphor

Symbolism and metaphor are often used to convey subtext. In literature and film, objects, colors, and settings can all carry symbolic meanings that suggest deeper themes. For example, a character might be associated with a specific color, animal, or item that reflects their inner world or emotional state.

5. Context and Backstory

A character's backstory and past experiences influence their subtext. Understanding a character's history, relationships, and fears allows the audience to interpret their actions and words in a more meaningful way. When a character makes a seemingly innocuous comment, understanding their context can reveal hidden layers of meaning.

6. Dual Meanings in Dialogue

When writing dialogue or creating a scene, layering dual meanings into your words can create rich subtext. A simple statement like, "I'll see you around," might have different meanings depending on the relationship and context. It could imply a casual goodbye, or it could suggest finality and distance, depending on the tone, body language, and situation.

7. Pacing and Timing

The timing of how things are revealed also plays a critical role in creating subtext. By pacing the narrative carefully, you can allow the audience to anticipate what is coming, creating tension and engagement. A slow reveal or a sudden twist can make the subtext feel even more impactful.

Conclusion

Subtext is a nuanced and essential part of storytelling, communication, and art. It is the unspoken language that adds depth, complexity, and emotional resonance to any narrative. Mastering subtext involves understanding the power of silence, nonverbal cues, contradictions, and metaphor. It requires an ability to weave multiple layers of meaning into your work, allowing your audience to engage with it in a more profound way. Whether you're a writer, actor, artist, or consumer of media, understanding and utilizing subtext can enhance your ability to both create and interpret meaningful content.

View Product