How to Make a Checklist for Running Effective Reference Checks

Reference checks are a crucial part of the hiring process. They provide insights into a candidate's work ethic, character, and past job performance. However, conducting an effective reference check requires careful preparation and execution. A well-structured checklist can help ensure that reference checks are thorough, consistent, and informative.

In this actionable guide, we will explore the steps to create a checklist for running effective reference checks. The goal is to provide a step-by-step process that recruiters, HR professionals, or hiring managers can use to gather reliable and useful information.

Understand the Purpose of a Reference Check

Before diving into the checklist, it's important to understand why reference checks are necessary. Reference checks are typically used to:

• Verify the information provided by the candidate (e.g., job history, roles, and responsibilities).
• Gain insights into the candidate's work performance, personality, and interpersonal skills.
• Confirm that the candidate's qualifications align with the company's needs.
• Identify potential red flags or concerns that were not addressed during the interview process.

Understanding these objectives will guide the types of questions and areas of focus for your checklist.

Prepare for the Reference Check

Preparation is key to ensuring the reference check is effective. A disorganized or rushed approach may lead to missed opportunities for valuable insights. Here's how to prepare:

a. Identify the Right References

When asking candidates for references, always request individuals who are in a position to speak knowledgeably about the candidate's work performance. Generally, you should request:

• Supervisors or Managers: They can provide feedback on the candidate's job performance, strengths, and areas for improvement.
• Colleagues or Team Members: Peer references can give insight into how well the candidate works with others, their communication skills, and their ability to collaborate.
• Subordinates (if applicable): If the candidate has held managerial positions, getting feedback from those who reported to them can be useful for assessing leadership skills.

Avoid personal references, such as friends or family members, as they won't provide objective or relevant information about the candidate's professional abilities.

b. Gather Necessary Information

Ensure you have all the necessary information before conducting the reference check. This includes:

• The candidate's resume and application details.
• The specific role or position for which the candidate is being considered.
• Any specific skills or qualities you are looking for based on the job description (e.g., leadership, problem-solving, teamwork).

c. Set Up the Logistics

Decide on the method of communication (phone, email, or video) and schedule the reference check with enough time to ensure you can discuss the necessary points without rushing. Make sure to inform the reference in advance about the purpose of the call, the role the candidate is applying for, and the expected duration.

Create the Reference Check Checklist

Now that you have prepared, it's time to create your checklist. A well-structured checklist ensures that you cover all necessary areas and maintain consistency across different reference checks. Below are the key elements to include in your checklist.

a. Basic Information

Start by verifying basic details about the candidate and their role at the previous organization. This provides clarity and establishes a baseline for the rest of the conversation.

• Confirm Employment Dates: Ask for confirmation of the candidate's start and end dates.
• Job Title and Role: Verify the candidate's job title and the main responsibilities they held.
• Reason for Leaving: Inquire why the candidate left the company or is seeking new opportunities (if applicable).

b. Work Performance

This section is crucial as it helps you understand how well the candidate performed in their previous role.

• Key Responsibilities: Ask the reference to describe the candidate's primary duties and responsibilities. This helps confirm whether the candidate's skills match the job description.
• Achievements and Contributions: Request examples of the candidate's accomplishments during their tenure. Were there any significant projects or goals they contributed to? How did they add value to the team or organization?
• Quality of Work: Ask about the candidate's attention to detail, accuracy, and ability to meet deadlines. Did they consistently produce high-quality work?
• Problem-Solving and Critical Thinking: How did the candidate handle challenges or unexpected issues? Were they able to resolve problems effectively and with minimal supervision?

c. Work Ethic and Professionalism

This section assesses the candidate's attitude, commitment, and reliability.

• Dependability and Attendance: Inquire about the candidate's reliability in terms of showing up to work, adhering to schedules, and maintaining consistent attendance.
• Punctuality and Time Management: Ask about their ability to manage their time effectively and meet deadlines.
• Work Style: Does the candidate work independently or require frequent guidance? Are they able to stay motivated and productive with minimal supervision?
• Adaptability: How well does the candidate handle change or new situations? Are they open to learning and taking on new tasks?

d. Interpersonal Skills and Teamwork

It's important to evaluate how the candidate interacts with others in a work setting.

• Collaboration and Teamwork: How does the candidate work within a team? Are they cooperative and willing to collaborate, or do they prefer to work alone?
• Communication Skills: Inquire about the candidate's ability to communicate clearly and effectively with colleagues, managers, and clients.
• Conflict Resolution: Has the candidate ever been involved in resolving workplace conflicts? How do they handle disagreements or difficult conversations?
• Leadership Potential (if applicable): If the candidate has held leadership roles, ask about their ability to manage and motivate a team. How do they handle responsibility and decision-making?

e. Strengths and Areas for Improvement

Every candidate has areas where they excel and areas where they may need improvement. This section helps you assess the candidate's fit for the role based on these traits.

• Strengths: What would the reference say are the candidate's greatest strengths? Are these strengths aligned with the role they're applying for?
• Areas for Development: Are there any skills or areas the candidate needs to improve upon? Are these areas critical to the position they are being considered for?
• Potential for Growth: Does the reference believe the candidate has the potential to grow within the company or industry? Are they open to feedback and improvement?

f. Final Assessment and Recommendation

This section allows the reference to provide an overall assessment of the candidate.

• Would You Rehire Them?: This is one of the most telling questions. Ask if the reference would hire the candidate again or if they would recommend them for the role.
• Overall Rating: How would the reference rate the candidate overall (e.g., excellent, good, average, poor)?
• Additional Comments: Give the reference space to provide any additional comments, concerns, or context that may not have been covered by the previous questions.

Conduct the Reference Check

With your checklist in hand, it's time to conduct the reference check. Here are some tips to ensure the process is as effective as possible:

• Be Professional and Respectful: Treat the reference with respect and professionalism. Remember that they are providing valuable insight, so make sure the conversation is cordial.
• Take Notes: Write down the responses to your questions. This will help you make informed decisions and reference the details later when reviewing the candidate.
• Ask Follow-Up Questions: If a reference provides an answer that's unclear or needs more detail, don't hesitate to ask for clarification or examples.
• Be Objective: Keep in mind that references may have biases---whether positive or negative. Try to assess the responses objectively and corroborate them with other information from the interview or the candidate's application.

Analyze the Results

Once you've completed the reference checks, review the information collected. Compare the feedback from multiple references to identify any patterns or discrepancies. The insights gained from reference checks should provide a more complete picture of the candidate's abilities, personality, and fit for the role.

If there are any concerning or conflicting responses, follow up with the candidate for clarification. In some cases, it may be worth conducting a second round of reference checks or seeking additional opinions.

Conclusion

Reference checks are an essential part of the hiring process, and having a clear, structured checklist ensures that you gather all the relevant information to make an informed decision. By following the steps outlined in this guide, you can create a comprehensive checklist that helps you assess candidates fairly and thoroughly. Properly executed, reference checks can significantly enhance your recruitment process and help you hire the best talent for your organization.

View Product