How to Discuss a Movie's Subtlety vs. Overtness

Movies, as a form of art, often evoke a wide range of reactions. Audiences may find themselves enthralled by a film's depth, emotional resonance, or the underlying messages conveyed through characters and scenes. One of the most compelling aspects of cinema is how it communicates these messages. Some films choose to express their themes subtly, relying on nuances, silence, and restrained performances. Others opt for overt expressions of meaning, where the themes, emotions, or conflicts are presented in a direct, unmistakable manner. Understanding the balance between subtlety and overtness is essential for anyone analyzing film, as it shapes how a movie resonates with its audience.

This article aims to explore the ways in which films use subtlety and overtness, how to identify and discuss these aspects, and how they affect the overall impact of a movie. It will also delve into the historical context of these approaches, the various techniques filmmakers use to achieve both subtle and overt expressions, and the significance of audience interpretation in determining the success of these strategies.

Understanding Subtlety in Film

Subtlety in film refers to the art of conveying ideas, emotions, or themes in a way that isn't immediately obvious. Rather than laying everything out in an explicit manner, subtle films rely on implication, suggestion, and visual or auditory cues to create a more nuanced understanding of the story. Subtlety in cinema encourages viewers to engage actively with the material, interpreting and piecing together information over time. It demands attention to detail and often rewards repeat viewings.

Subtlety can manifest in various forms, including:

1. Visual Subtlety

In visually subtle films, the director often uses mise-en-scène (the arrangement of everything that appears on screen) to communicate deeper meanings. This could involve the use of lighting, framing, color palettes, and spatial composition. For example, the way a character is framed in a small corner of the screen might suggest feelings of isolation or insignificance, without explicitly stating it.

Consider the film Lost in Translation (2003), where director Sofia Coppola uses visual cues to communicate the emotional distance between the two protagonists. Instead of overtly stating their isolation, the film uses wide shots of their surroundings, showing the protagonists in large, empty spaces, symbolizing their loneliness in the midst of a foreign city. These visual choices are subtle in their delivery, yet powerfully effective in conveying the theme.

2. Dialogue and Characterization

Subtlety in dialogue often involves what is unsaid as much as what is said. A character may speak in vague, indirect terms, or their true emotions may be concealed behind polite words or sarcasm. This type of subtlety often relies on the actor's ability to convey complex emotions through micro-expressions and body language. In these cases, the true meaning is implied through context rather than directly communicated.

In The Graduate (1967), Benjamin Braddock's interactions with Mrs. Robinson and his parents are filled with subtle tensions that are never fully addressed. The awkward pauses and indirect ways in which they communicate highlight the confusion and dissatisfaction brewing under the surface. The audience is left to interpret the discontent without it being explicitly verbalized.

3. Symbolism and Metaphor

Films often use symbolism and metaphor to convey complex ideas in subtle ways. Rather than showing a character's emotional state directly, a filmmaker might use recurring images, objects, or colors to represent specific emotions or themes. These symbols often carry layers of meaning, which can be understood through careful observation and analysis.

A classic example of this is Stanley Kubrick's The Shining (1980), where the use of color, setting, and patterns plays a significant role in conveying the psychological deterioration of the main character. The film doesn't explicitly explain the descent into madness but uses its visual language to suggest it. The presence of the Overlook Hotel as a malevolent force, the strange labyrinths of the hallways, and the symbolic use of the hedge maze all contribute to a sense of entrapment and confusion, offering a deeper interpretation of Jack Torrance's state of mind.

4. Pacing and Timing

Subtlety can also be achieved through pacing and timing. A slow-paced narrative, long takes, or moments of silence can create a sense of unease or contemplation. These elements allow the audience to linger on the details, forcing them to pay attention to what's happening in the background or in the quiet moments between characters.

In There Will Be Blood (2007), Paul Thomas Anderson uses long takes and slow pacing to build tension and highlight the internal struggles of the characters. The film's use of silence, particularly during scenes of conflict or contemplation, emphasizes the isolation and internal conflict of the characters. This gradual buildup allows the viewer to interpret the growing intensity without it being overtly spelled out.

Understanding Overtness in Film

Overtness, on the other hand, refers to the explicit, direct expression of a film's themes or emotions. Films that are overt often present their ideas in a clear, unambiguous manner. The director or screenwriter may choose to directly state the themes or emotions through dialogue, visual storytelling, or plot development. While overt films may lack the subtlety of their counterparts, they often make their messages immediately accessible to a broader audience, leaving little room for ambiguity.

Overtness can manifest in various ways:

1. Explicit Dialogue

Overt films often feature characters who openly discuss their emotions, motivations, or conflicts. There's little left to interpretation, as the film's themes are directly addressed through conversations and monologues. This can sometimes result in a more straightforward, less layered experience for the audience.

An example of overt dialogue can be seen in Dead Poets Society (1989), where the characters frequently articulate their feelings and beliefs. Robin Williams' character, John Keating, directly challenges societal norms and encourages his students to think for themselves. The themes of individualism and the struggle against authority are made clear through explicit dialogue, leaving little room for subtlety.

2. Direct Visual Expression

Overtness in visual storytelling often involves presenting the film's themes in a clear and obvious manner. This could include bold use of color, lighting, or imagery to emphasize particular ideas or emotions. In these cases, the visual style works in tandem with the narrative to ensure that the audience immediately grasps the meaning.

The 2014 film The Imitation Game provides a clear example of overt visual storytelling, especially in its depiction of Alan Turing's emotional state. The stark contrast between the cold, sterile environments of the government facility and Turing's internal struggles makes his isolation and personal conflict apparent to the audience. These overt visual cues help communicate Turing's loneliness and persecution without relying on subtlety.

3. Plot and Character Development

Overt films often rely on their plot structure and character development to make the themes clear. Characters might undergo dramatic transformations or face clear moral dilemmas that guide the audience's understanding of the film's message. In these films, there's little need for the viewer to dig deeper into subtext or symbolism because the story's moral or theme is spelled out through the narrative.

In The Pursuit of Happyness (2006), the film's plot directly showcases the hardships and ultimate triumph of Chris Gardner. The overt nature of the story's message---perseverance leads to success---is communicated through the character's actions and the obstacles he faces. The audience is led step-by-step through the character's journey, making the film's intentions clear.

4. Use of Music and Soundtrack

In overt films, music and sound are often used as emotional cues to directly tell the audience how to feel. A swelling orchestral score or an upbeat pop song can make it immediately obvious how the filmmakers want the audience to respond to a scene. While music can certainly be used subtly, overt films often rely on it to heighten the emotional impact of a scene in a direct, unambiguous way.

The use of music in The Lion King (1994) is a perfect example of overt sound design. The iconic score and songs like "Circle of Life" or "Hakuna Matata" provide clear emotional guidance, helping the audience understand the characters' emotions and the overarching themes of life, death, and community.

Subtlety vs. Overtness: A Balance of Approaches

While subtlety and overtness can seem like opposing approaches, many successful films strike a balance between the two. A filmmaker may choose to use subtlety in some scenes while employing overt techniques in others to create emotional contrast and narrative depth. The balance between subtlety and overtness can influence the pace of the film, the engagement of the audience, and the emotional resonance of the narrative.

For example, in Schindler's List (1993), Steven Spielberg uses both subtle and overt storytelling techniques. The film's harrowing portrayal of the Holocaust is made both explicit through the shocking violence of the concentration camps and subtle through the quiet moments of Oskar Schindler's transformation. The film's use of color (such as the famous red coat) subtly directs the audience's focus, while the characters' direct actions and dialogue make the moral themes overtly clear.

The Role of the Audience

The way a film's subtlety or overtness is received often depends on the audience's level of engagement and personal interpretation. A more passive viewer may appreciate the overt aspects of a film, while an active viewer might prefer to unpack the layers of subtlety. The extent to which a viewer grasps a film's meaning can depend on their cultural background, previous experiences with cinema, and individual perspective.

Films that rely on subtlety often demand more effort from the viewer, requiring them to pay close attention to the finer details and interpret the underlying themes. Overt films, by contrast, tend to guide the audience's emotions and responses more directly, making them accessible to a wider range of viewers but potentially less satisfying for those seeking deeper meaning.

Conclusion

When discussing a movie's subtlety vs. overtness, it's important to recognize that both approaches have their merits and limitations. Subtle films offer complexity and invite personal interpretation, often leaving a lasting impression on those willing to engage deeply with the material. Overt films, meanwhile, provide clarity and directness, offering a more immediate emotional impact.

The key to a meaningful discussion of film lies in recognizing how these two approaches work together to shape the viewer's experience. Whether subtle or overt, every element of a film---be it dialogue, visual composition, or narrative structure---contributes to the broader themes and emotional resonance. By understanding the distinctions between subtlety and overtness, and how each affects the audience, we can gain a richer appreciation of the art of filmmaking.

View Product