How to Create a Checklist for Providing Employee References After Offboarding

Offboarding is an essential part of the employee lifecycle, and one often-overlooked aspect of this process is the provision of employee references. A reference can significantly impact an employee's career prospects after they leave your organization. Whether they're moving to a new role, seeking further educational opportunities, or pursuing freelance work, a solid reference from a past employer can make a world of difference.

Creating a checklist for providing references ensures that you maintain a consistent, fair, and legal approach. This guide will help you build an actionable checklist that covers all aspects of reference provision, from legal considerations to the emotional aspects of giving feedback on past employees.

Understand the Legal Implications

Before providing an employee reference, it's important to understand the legal ramifications. In some regions, employers may be liable for providing misleading or false references that could harm the employee's chances of securing a new job. Therefore, the first step in your checklist should involve an understanding of the legal framework within which you operate.

Steps to Take:

• Consult with Legal or HR Experts: Have your company's legal team or HR department review your reference policies to ensure they align with current laws and best practices. This ensures you're providing references in a legally responsible way.
• Ensure Accuracy: References should be fact-based and free from opinions or personal biases. Avoid including anything that could be construed as discriminatory.
• Avoid Defamation: Be cautious about including negative comments that could be interpreted as slander or libel. Stick to facts, and avoid making statements that could harm the employee's reputation unnecessarily.

Set Clear Guidelines for When You Will Provide a Reference

A well-structured reference policy helps employees know what to expect and ensures consistency across the organization. Establish clear guidelines about when and how references will be given.

Steps to Take:

• Eligibility for Reference: Not every employee may qualify for a reference. Outline which employees will be eligible, such as those who have had a positive performance record and have left the company on good terms.
• Voluntary vs. Required References: Decide whether references will be given only when requested by the employee, or if you will provide references automatically to those who meet the eligibility criteria.
• Reference Types: Determine the type of reference you will provide. For example:
  • General Reference: A simple, factual statement confirming employment dates, positions held, and general duties performed.
  • Detailed Reference: A more comprehensive assessment of the employee's skills, work ethic, and contributions.

Checklist Item:

• Clearly communicate whether references are automatic or must be requested.
• Define which employees are eligible for a reference (e.g., positive performance reviews, good standing at the time of departure).

Collect and Organize Relevant Information

Providing a thoughtful and comprehensive reference requires that you have all the necessary information at hand. This ensures that your reference is accurate and fair.

Steps to Take:

• Employment Records: Ensure you have up-to-date and accurate records of the employee's time at your company. This includes job titles, dates of employment, and a list of responsibilities and achievements.
• Performance Reviews: Gather any performance reviews or feedback that can help support the reference. Positive reviews and feedback from colleagues, managers, or clients can be used to highlight the employee's strengths.
• Key Contributions: Identify any major projects or achievements the employee was involved in, as these will serve as examples of their capabilities and value to the company.

Checklist Item:

• Review the employee's file to ensure you have a comprehensive record of their employment, including performance evaluations, achievements, and key projects.

Decide on the Format of the Reference

Once you've collected all the necessary information, decide on the format of the reference. The two most common formats are written references and verbal references.

Steps to Take:

• Written Reference: A formal, written reference is often the preferred option as it provides a permanent record. This should be a concise and professional letter or document that includes the employee's key strengths and the duration of their employment.

  • Make sure the letter includes:
    • A clear statement of the employee's job title and employment dates.
    • A brief overview of their key responsibilities and performance.
    • Positive feedback highlighting the employee's strengths and achievements.
    • A statement of endorsement (if applicable) or a neutral tone if the employee did not leave on the best of terms.

• Verbal Reference: Some employers may prefer to provide verbal references. While these may be quicker, they should still be handled with care to ensure consistency and legality.

  • Have a script or key talking points ready, especially if multiple people might be asked to provide a verbal reference for the same employee.

Checklist Item:

• Decide in advance whether you will provide written or verbal references, or both.
• Prepare templates or scripts for reference letters and verbal references to ensure consistency.

Maintain Confidentiality and Privacy

One of the most important aspects of providing employee references is protecting the privacy and confidentiality of the individual. You should only share information that the employee has authorized you to share, and always respect their privacy.

Steps to Take:

• Seek Permission: Before providing a reference, confirm with the employee whether they consent to you sharing certain information with prospective employers. This consent should be in writing, especially when releasing sensitive information such as performance reviews.
• Avoid Sharing Private Information: Do not disclose any private information that is irrelevant to the employee's work performance. This could include personal or medical details or anything related to their departure unless the employee gives specific permission.

Checklist Item:

• Always seek written consent from the employee before providing a reference.
• Avoid sharing any personal or irrelevant information that could violate confidentiality.

Tailor the Reference to the Employee's Future Role

An effective reference should be tailored to suit the specific role or opportunity the employee is seeking. A one-size-fits-all reference may not provide the potential employer with the relevant insights they need.

Steps to Take:

• Understand the Role: If possible, try to get a sense of the role the employee is applying for so you can provide relevant feedback about their experience and skills.
• Highlight Relevant Skills: Focus on the skills, qualifications, and accomplishments that are most relevant to the new position. For example, if the employee is applying for a management role, emphasize their leadership and decision-making abilities.
• Provide Specific Examples: If possible, offer specific examples of the employee's work that demonstrate their competence in areas relevant to the role they are pursuing.

Checklist Item:

• Request details from the employee about the job they are applying for, and customize the reference to highlight relevant skills and experiences.

Review and Finalize the Reference

Before sending or providing the reference, it's essential to review it for accuracy, professionalism, and completeness. This final step ensures that your reference is a true and fair reflection of the employee's time with your organization.

Steps to Take:

• Proofread: Check the reference for spelling, grammar, and factual errors. A well-written reference reflects well on both the employee and your company.
• Ensure Consistency: If your company has multiple individuals providing references, ensure there is consistency in the messaging and tone.
• Neutral Tone for Sensitive Cases: If the employee did not leave on the best terms, focus on providing a neutral, fact-based reference that doesn't delve into any personal feelings or judgments.

Checklist Item:

• Proofread the reference letter or script to ensure accuracy and professionalism.
• Maintain a neutral tone in case of any sensitive circumstances regarding the employee's departure.

Conclusion

Providing a reference after offboarding is a process that requires careful planning, accuracy, and sensitivity. By following a structured checklist, you ensure that your references are fair, legally sound, and beneficial to both the employee and your company's reputation. Establishing clear guidelines and maintaining consistency in your reference process will also help reduce the administrative burden and streamline the offboarding process for both employees and HR professionals alike.

View Product