How to Choose the Best Supernatural TV Shows

Supernatural TV shows have been a popular genre for decades, offering audiences a thrilling blend of mystery, horror, and often, the unexplained. These shows provide the perfect escape into worlds where the laws of nature bend and break, where the supernatural reigns, and where heroes battle against otherworldly forces. Whether it's vampires, ghosts, witches, or mythical creatures, supernatural TV shows are known for their compelling characters, intense storylines, and spine-chilling suspense.

However, with so many supernatural TV shows to choose from, how does one determine which ones are worth investing time in? This article will delve into how to choose the best supernatural TV shows by considering various aspects such as plot, character development, themes, atmosphere, viewer engagement, and critical reception.

Understanding What Makes a Supernatural TV Show Stand Out

Before diving into the specifics of choosing the best supernatural TV shows, it's important to understand the core components that make these shows so intriguing.

1. The Supernatural Element: Supernatural shows often blur the line between reality and the impossible, whether through magic, ghosts, or other unexplained phenomena. The central supernatural element drives the plot and fuels conflict, making it a key aspect to consider when choosing a show.
2. World-Building and Mythology: Strong supernatural shows create rich, expansive worlds with unique mythologies. This could include complex universes with their own set of rules, histories, and cultures. The depth of the world-building often determines the long-term appeal of a show.
3. Character Development: While the supernatural aspects of a show are crucial, character development is often what makes or breaks a series. Whether the characters are struggling with their own dark secrets or trying to come to terms with their powers, well-developed characters make the plot more engaging.
4. Atmosphere and Tone: Supernatural shows often evoke specific moods, from dark and eerie to lighthearted and humorous. The tone sets the stage for how the supernatural elements are presented and how the audience feels about the unfolding story.
5. Engaging Plotlines: A strong supernatural show typically weaves intricate plots filled with twists and turns. It challenges the audience's expectations and often leads them on a journey of discovery.

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing the Best Supernatural TV Shows

1. Genre Preferences

Supernatural TV shows are not confined to one genre. They can be a mix of horror, mystery, thriller, fantasy, drama, or even comedy. The first step in selecting the right supernatural show is understanding your genre preferences.

• Horror and Thriller : If you enjoy spine-chilling moments and tense, terrifying experiences, shows that focus on ghosts, demons, or dark magic might be your best bet. Series like The Haunting of Hill House , Stranger Things , and Supernatural offer plenty of suspense and scare-factor.
• Fantasy and Adventure : For those who prefer epic storytelling with magical creatures and grand battles between good and evil, shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer , The Witcher , or Supernatural offer both the supernatural elements and high-stakes adventure.
• Comedy and Lightheartedness : There's also a subgenre of supernatural TV that leans more toward humor, blending the supernatural with comedy. The Good Place , What We Do in the Shadows , and Buffy the Vampire Slayer in its earlier seasons offer a lighter take on the supernatural world.
• Drama and Family Focused : Some supernatural shows delve deeply into the characters' personal lives, weaving in emotional complexity and family dynamics. The Vampire Diaries , Charmed , and The Originals balance supernatural elements with family and romantic relationships.

Understanding your preferred genre will help you narrow down your options, as supernatural TV shows can be tailored to different tastes.

2. Plot Complexity and Pacing

The pacing and complexity of a supernatural TV show are crucial factors in determining its appeal. Some viewers prefer a fast-paced narrative with multiple story arcs happening simultaneously, while others appreciate a slow-burn approach where the supernatural elements gradually unfold.

• Slow-Burn Drama : Some shows, like The X-Files or Stranger Things, rely on a methodical build-up, gradually revealing the core mysteries while keeping viewers on the edge of their seats. These shows often feature episodic mysteries but develop overarching narratives over time.
• Fast-Paced and Action-Oriented : For those who want non-stop action and quick resolutions, shows like Supernatural , Teen Wolf , and Constantine offer fast-paced episodes filled with action, combat, and supernatural battles.
• Layered Plotlines and Mythology : Supernatural shows with intricate world-building and expansive mythologies, such as Buffy the Vampire Slayer or The Witcher, can keep you engaged for multiple seasons. These shows tend to involve complex plots with interconnected character arcs and hidden lore.

If you prefer a slower, more thoughtful show that builds tension over time, look for series that are known for their intricate storytelling. If you enjoy action and high-intensity drama, go for something with faster pacing.

3. Character Development and Relationships

In the world of supernatural TV shows, character development is paramount. You want to connect with the characters, understand their motivations, and be invested in their growth. A show that focuses on strong character arcs will have a lasting impact on viewers.

• Relatable Protagonists : The best supernatural shows often feature relatable protagonists who are navigating their extraordinary abilities. Buffy Summers from Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Sam and Dean Winchester from Supernatural are iconic characters with emotional depth, struggling with their roles in the supernatural world while dealing with personal dilemmas.
• Character Dynamics : Some shows shine because of the relationships between characters. Whether it's the sibling dynamic between Sam and Dean in Supernatural , the romantic entanglements in The Vampire Diaries , or the camaraderie in Stranger Things, these relationships elevate the storytelling.
• Villains and Antagonists : The presence of well-developed villains can also make a supernatural show stand out. The antagonist can be as compelling as the hero, if not more. The Witcher offers Geralt of Rivia as a strong yet morally ambiguous character, while The Vampire Diaries features powerful villains with complex backstories.

When choosing a supernatural show, think about whether you want to focus on character-driven narratives or if you are more interested in the supernatural events themselves.

4. Themes and Message

Many supernatural TV shows offer more than just thrills and chills; they explore deep themes related to humanity, society, and personal struggles. These themes can resonate with viewers on a deeper level, making a show more memorable.

• Identity and Self-Discovery : Many supernatural shows, particularly those centered around young adults, deal with the theme of identity and self-discovery. Characters like Buffy Summers and the Teen Wolf protagonist Scott McCall must grapple with their newfound powers while learning about who they truly are.
• Good vs. Evil : The eternal struggle between good and evil is a common theme in supernatural TV shows. Shows like Supernatural and The Witcher explore this dynamic in epic proportions, often asking tough moral questions along the way.
• Social and Political Commentary : Some supernatural TV shows take the opportunity to comment on societal issues. For example, The X-Files often included political commentary through its stories about government cover-ups, while Buffy the Vampire Slayer used the supernatural as a metaphor for high school struggles and real-life challenges.
• Redemption and Forgiveness : Shows like The Vampire Diaries focus on themes of redemption, where characters must confront their dark pasts and find ways to redeem themselves. This theme often resonates with viewers who enjoy seeing flawed characters grow and evolve.

If you're drawn to a particular theme or social commentary, that could help guide you toward a supernatural show that aligns with your interests.

5. Critical Reception and Viewer Feedback

Critical reception and audience feedback are also significant factors when choosing a supernatural TV show. Before committing to a series, consider looking at reviews, audience ratings, and discussions on social media or forums.

• Rotten Tomatoes and IMDb Ratings: Websites like Rotten Tomatoes and IMDb provide user reviews and ratings that can offer insight into a show's overall quality. A show with high ratings and positive feedback from both critics and viewers is often a safe bet.
• Fan Communities: Many supernatural TV shows have dedicated fan communities that discuss episodes, characters, and theories. Exploring these fan spaces can give you a sense of the show's cultural impact and how invested people are in the series.
• Awards and Nominations: Some of the best supernatural TV shows are often recognized at major awards ceremonies. Nominations and wins at the Golden Globes, Emmys, or other prestigious awards can signal high quality in a show's writing, acting, and production.

Conclusion: Choosing the Best Supernatural TV Shows

Choosing the best supernatural TV shows ultimately depends on your personal preferences, tastes, and what you're looking for in a series. Whether you're into spine-tingling horror, complex fantasy worlds, character-driven drama, or light-hearted supernatural comedy, there's something out there for you.

By considering factors like genre, plot complexity, character development, themes, and the show's critical reception, you can make an informed decision that leads you to a supernatural series that not only thrills but also leaves a lasting impression. The beauty of the supernatural genre is its vastness and its ability to blend genres, so take your time, explore different options, and enjoy the otherworldly ride!

View Product