How to Build a Checklist for Setting Expectations with Your Manager During Performance Evaluations

Performance evaluations are a crucial part of professional development. They are a time to assess your progress, set new goals, and clarify what is expected of you moving forward. But, how do you ensure that both you and your manager are aligned during this important conversation? Building a checklist for setting expectations can help you stay focused, track your goals, and ensure that both you and your manager have a clear understanding of what success looks like.

Here's an actionable guide to creating a comprehensive checklist to set expectations effectively during your performance evaluation.

Understand the Purpose of Performance Evaluations

Before creating your checklist, it's essential to understand why performance evaluations are conducted. They aren't just a formality or a review of past work; these evaluations are an opportunity for both you and your manager to:

• Assess your achievements and progress.
• Identify areas of improvement.
• Align on goals and future expectations.
• Provide constructive feedback.
• Ensure that your contributions are recognized.

Having a clear understanding of the purpose of your evaluation allows you to frame the conversation in a way that supports both personal growth and organizational objectives.

Set Clear Goals and Objectives

The foundation of setting expectations with your manager is ensuring that you both agree on the goals you're working toward. These goals should be specific, measurable, and realistic. Here's how to approach it:

a. Reflect on Your Past Performance

Before the evaluation, take time to assess your past performance. Look at what you've accomplished, challenges you've faced, and areas where you could have done better. This will give you context for setting future goals.

Actionable Steps:

• Review your job description and past goals.
• Reflect on how well you've met those goals and identify any gaps.
• Consider feedback from peers or colleagues, if available.

b. Align with Your Manager's Expectations

Setting expectations isn't a one-way street; it's about mutual understanding. Make sure to align with your manager on what success looks like in your role and within the team.

Actionable Steps:

• Ask your manager about key performance indicators (KPIs) for your role.
• Discuss both long-term and short-term goals.
• Make sure your goals are in line with the company's overall mission and objectives.

c. Use the SMART Framework

The SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) framework is a great tool for setting clear and actionable goals.

Actionable Steps:

• Specific: Clearly define what you want to achieve.
• Measurable: Determine how you will measure your success.
• Achievable: Set realistic goals based on your current capabilities and resources.
• Relevant: Ensure the goal aligns with your career objectives and the team's needs.
• Time-bound: Establish a clear timeline for reaching your goals.

Address Areas for Improvement

No one is perfect, and performance evaluations are an opportunity to address areas for growth. Having a constructive conversation about your weaknesses is crucial to improving your performance.

a. Be Open to Feedback

Your manager might highlight areas where you could improve. Instead of getting defensive, approach these discussions with a growth mindset. Acknowledge the feedback, and seek actionable advice on how to improve.

Actionable Steps:

• Actively listen to feedback without interrupting.
• Ask for specific examples of where improvements are needed.
• Discuss the tools, resources, or training you need to improve.

b. Set Development Goals

Once areas for improvement are identified, set development goals to address these gaps. This could involve enhancing specific skills, working on communication, or improving time management.

Actionable Steps:

• Identify key skills you need to develop.
• Create a plan for how you will develop these skills (e.g., online courses, mentoring, practice).
• Set realistic deadlines for improvement and track progress over time.

Clarify Resources and Support Needed

Having clear expectations is important, but so is understanding what resources and support you need from your manager to succeed. Whether it's access to specific tools, training, or regular feedback, be proactive in asking for what you need.

a. Identify Needed Resources

Think about the resources that could help you reach your goals more effectively. This could include tools, software, training programs, or additional team support.

Actionable Steps:

• List the resources that would improve your productivity or skills.
• Discuss these resources with your manager to see if they are feasible.
• Set a timeline for acquiring or implementing these resources.

b. Request Regular Check-ins

Setting expectations is an ongoing process. It's helpful to ask your manager for regular check-ins to review progress, address challenges, and provide feedback. These check-ins can help ensure that both you and your manager stay on the same page.

Actionable Steps:

• Propose regular one-on-one meetings to review your progress.
• Use these meetings to adjust goals or timelines if necessary.
• Be open to adjusting your goals based on changing circumstances.

Establish a Timeline for Review

Setting expectations isn't just about the conversation; it's also about tracking progress over time. Having a clear timeline for how often you'll review your goals and performance can help ensure accountability.

a. Define Milestones

Break down your goals into smaller, measurable milestones. This helps track progress and allows for easier adjustments along the way.

Actionable Steps:

• Define specific milestones for each goal.
• Set deadlines for these milestones.
• Review progress regularly and adjust goals if needed.

b. Align Evaluation with Company Cycles

Most organizations have annual or semi-annual performance reviews. Ensure that your goals are aligned with these cycles so that you can have meaningful conversations about your progress during these evaluations.

Actionable Steps:

• Sync your goal timeline with the company's performance review cycle.
• Plan for periodic check-ins leading up to the formal review.

Document and Follow Up

Finally, documentation is key to holding both you and your manager accountable. Write down the key points from the performance evaluation, including the goals, expectations, and any action items discussed.

a. Create a Written Record

After the evaluation, create a document outlining the key points of your discussion. This will serve as a reference point for both you and your manager to revisit as needed.

Actionable Steps:

• Write down the SMART goals, timelines, and milestones.
• Include any feedback, resources, or support that was discussed.
• Share this document with your manager to ensure mutual understanding.

b. Follow Up Regularly

Don't wait until the next performance review to revisit your goals. Regularly check in with your manager to provide updates and get feedback.

Actionable Steps:

• Send periodic updates on your progress.
• Reach out to discuss any challenges or adjustments needed.
• Revisit your checklist if necessary and adjust based on feedback.

Conclusion

Building a checklist for setting expectations with your manager during performance evaluations is about ensuring alignment, tracking progress, and fostering open communication. By taking a proactive approach to goal-setting, addressing areas for improvement, and seeking the support you need, you can not only improve your performance but also show your commitment to your professional growth. Use the strategies in this guide to create a checklist that will help you get the most out of your performance evaluations and set yourself up for continued success.

View Product