How to Build a Checklist for Reviewing Headlines and Subheadings

When writing content, headlines and subheadings are critical to capturing your audience's attention and guiding them through the material. They not only serve as the first impression but also help improve readability and SEO. A well-crafted headline or subheading can entice readers to dive deeper into your content, while a poorly structured one may cause them to bounce off. In this guide, we will walk you through how to create a checklist that will help you review your headlines and subheadings effectively, ensuring that they perform at their best.

Why Headlines and Subheadings Matter

Before jumping into how to build a checklist, it's important to understand why headlines and subheadings are essential. Here are a few reasons:

1. First Impressions Count

The headline is the first thing your audience will see, and it typically determines whether or not they will continue reading. A compelling headline draws people in, while a dull one pushes them away.

2. Guiding the Reader

Subheadings act as signposts that guide the reader through the content. They break down the text into digestible sections and create a logical flow that makes the content easier to scan and understand.

3. SEO Impact

Search engines like Google consider headlines and subheadings as important signals for ranking. Properly optimized headlines and subheadings that include relevant keywords can improve your visibility in search results.

4. Enhanced Readability

Structuring your content with clear and engaging headlines and subheadings improves the overall readability of the piece. They help readers quickly find the information they are looking for and enhance user experience.

Key Components of Effective Headlines and Subheadings

Before diving into your checklist, let's break down what makes a headline or subheading effective:

Headlines

• Attention-Grabbing: It should instantly catch the reader's attention.
• Clear and Concise: Avoid jargon or overly complex phrasing.
• Relevance: Ensure the headline matches the content and fulfills the promise made in the title.
• Incorporates Keywords: For SEO purposes, ensure relevant keywords are included without keyword stuffing.
• Create Curiosity: A good headline sparks curiosity, encouraging the reader to explore further.

Subheadings

• Organized: Subheadings should be structured logically to break down content into clear sections.
• Scannable: Subheadings should help the reader scan the content easily, finding the sections that are most relevant to them.
• Descriptive: They should provide a snapshot of what each section is about, making it easier for readers to find what they are looking for.
• Engaging: Just like headlines, subheadings should encourage further reading.

How to Build Your Checklist

To ensure your headlines and subheadings are working to their fullest potential, you need to review them with a clear and actionable set of guidelines. Here's a step-by-step process for building your checklist:

1. Clarity and Simplicity

• Does the headline clearly convey the main point of the article or section?
  • A headline should immediately communicate what the content is about. Avoid overly abstract or unclear language. Keep it straightforward.
• Is the subheading clear and descriptive enough to indicate the content of that section?
  • Each subheading should describe exactly what the reader will learn in the section, making it easy to decide if they want to read it.

2. Relevance and Alignment

• Does the headline align with the content?
  • Double-check that the headline reflects the content it introduces. If the content doesn't meet the promise made by the headline, the reader will likely feel misled and lose trust.
• Do the subheadings align with the content they introduce?
  • Just as with headlines, subheadings should reflect the key points of the sections they introduce. They should act as a roadmap for the reader.

3. Engagement and Interest

• Does the headline generate curiosity or emotion?
  • A headline should make the reader want to know more. You can achieve this by posing questions, making bold statements, or offering solutions to common problems.
• Is the subheading interesting or thought-provoking?
  • While subheadings aren't as attention-grabbing as headlines, they should still maintain some level of intrigue. Subheadings like "Here's how..." or "What you need to know..." can spark curiosity.

4. Length and Conciseness

• Is the headline concise yet informative?
  • The ideal length for a headline is typically between 6-12 words. It should be short enough to be easily digestible but long enough to convey the necessary information.
• Are the subheadings concise but still meaningful?
  • Subheadings should also be succinct. Too long and they can become cumbersome, too short and they might lack the context needed to guide the reader.

5. Incorporating Keywords

• Does the headline include relevant keywords?
  • For SEO purposes, include the most relevant keywords in the headline. Ensure they are naturally placed within the headline to avoid looking forced.
• Are keywords naturally incorporated in the subheadings?
  • Subheadings are another opportunity to optimize your content for SEO. Include secondary keywords in your subheadings to further improve search rankings.

6. Tone and Voice

• Is the tone of the headline consistent with the content's tone?
  • The tone of your headline should match the tone of the article. If your content is serious, the headline should reflect that. If the content is light-hearted, the headline should have a more casual or fun tone.
• Is the tone of the subheading consistent with the section?
  • Subheadings should have a tone that aligns with the overall tone of the content. If one section is more formal, the subheading should reflect that, while a conversational section should have a more informal subheading.

7. Actionability

• Does the headline promise a benefit or outcome to the reader?
  • Readers often want to know what's in it for them. Your headline should suggest a solution, answer, or takeaway that motivates the reader to click through and engage.
• Do the subheadings guide the reader to actionable insights or solutions?
  • A subheading should signal that a section will help the reader solve a problem, gain insight, or learn something valuable.

8. Grammar and Spelling

• Is the headline free from spelling or grammatical errors?
  • A headline with errors reflects poorly on the quality of the content. Always double-check for typos or mistakes before publishing.
• Are the subheadings grammatically correct and properly structured?
  • Just like headlines, subheadings should be grammatically sound and well-constructed to maintain professionalism and readability.

Example of a Headline and Subheading Review Checklist

Here's a simple checklist you can use to review headlines and subheadings:

• Headline Review Checklist

  • [ ] Is the headline clear and straightforward?
  • [ ] Does it promise value to the reader?
  • [ ] Does it spark curiosity or emotion?
  • [ ] Is the length optimal (not too short or too long)?
  • [ ] Does it include relevant keywords?
  • [ ] Is it aligned with the content it introduces?
  • [ ] Is the tone consistent with the article?

• Subheading Review Checklist

  • [ ] Is the subheading clear and descriptive?
  • [ ] Does it break down the content logically?
  • [ ] Does it align with the section it introduces?
  • [ ] Is it concise and easy to read?
  • [ ] Does it support readability and scannability?
  • [ ] Does it include secondary keywords?
  • [ ] Is it grammatically correct?

Conclusion

A strong headline and subheading strategy can significantly improve the performance of your content, both in terms of reader engagement and SEO. By building a checklist that ensures clarity, relevance, engagement, and accuracy, you can ensure that your headlines and subheadings perform effectively. Keep this checklist handy whenever you're reviewing your content, and over time, you'll see improvements in how your content is received by your audience.

View Product