10 Tips Checklist for Self-Editing Fiction

Editing your own fiction is a crucial part of the writing process. While writing comes from inspiration, self-editing refines that initial spark into a polished, coherent, and compelling story. Often, authors face the dilemma of being too close to their own work, making it difficult to see mistakes or areas for improvement. However, with a strategic approach to editing, you can enhance your story's pacing, structure, and language. This checklist provides ten essential tips for self-editing fiction, helping you refine your work while maintaining its integrity and voice.

Take a Break Before You Begin

One of the most important steps in self-editing is to give yourself some distance from the manuscript. After completing your draft, set it aside for a few days or even a week. This break allows you to return to the work with fresh eyes, helping you identify areas that might need more attention. Distance helps you detach from your emotional investment in the story, making it easier to critique your work objectively.

Why this is important:

Taking a break helps you approach the manuscript from the perspective of a reader rather than a writer, allowing you to spot pacing issues, inconsistencies, and awkward phrasing more easily.

Start with Big Picture Edits

Before diving into line-by-line edits, focus on the structural elements of the story. This includes:

• Plot Structure: Does the plot make sense? Are there any plot holes, or does the story meander unnecessarily?
• Pacing: Does the story flow smoothly from scene to scene, or are there slow parts that drag the narrative?
• Character Development: Are your characters fully realized, and do their actions align with their motivations?
• Point of View: Is the narrative perspective consistent? Is the POV the most effective for the story?
• Themes and Message: Are the themes clear and consistent throughout the story? Does the narrative support the message you're trying to convey?

Why this is important:

Big-picture edits ensure that your story's foundation is strong. If your structure is flawed, fixing minor details won't matter. Once the plot, pacing, and character arcs are solid, you can move to more granular edits.

Read Aloud

Reading your manuscript aloud is one of the most effective ways to catch awkward phrasing, repetitive words, and unnatural dialogue. Your ears are often more sensitive to clumsy writing than your eyes. If a sentence sounds strange or a dialogue exchange feels stilted when spoken, it's a clear sign it needs revision.

Why this is important:

Reading aloud helps you identify issues with rhythm, dialogue flow, and pacing. It also allows you to hear how your characters' voices sound, which can reveal inconsistencies in tone.

Focus on Show, Don't Tell

"Show, don't tell" is one of the most common pieces of writing advice, and for a good reason. Telling, such as "She was angry," tends to be flat and uninspiring. Showing, such as "Her fists clenched, and her face turned red," paints a vivid picture for the reader. During your self-editing process, go through your manuscript and replace as many instances of "telling" with "showing."

Why this is important:

Showing engages readers more deeply and makes the narrative feel more immersive. It creates emotional resonance by letting readers experience events through the characters' senses and actions.

Cut Unnecessary Words

As writers, we tend to over-explain or over-describe, using extra words that do not add value to the story. In fiction, every word should serve a purpose, whether it's advancing the plot, revealing character, or building the world. During your editing process, scrutinize each sentence for words that can be cut, simplified, or rephrased.

Why this is important:

By eliminating unnecessary words, you tighten up your writing, making it more direct and impactful. This also improves pacing, ensuring that readers stay engaged and do not get bogged down by excess verbiage.

Check for Consistency

Inconsistencies in character behavior, setting, time, or tone can disrupt the reader's immersion in the story. As you self-edit, pay attention to:

• Character Traits: Does your character act in ways that are consistent with their personality, background, and motivations? If they suddenly act out of character, it should be a deliberate choice that is well-explained.
• Timeline: Are events happening in a logical, coherent order? Check for any inconsistencies in time or sequence of actions.
• Setting: Is your world-building consistent? Are places, locations, and descriptions accurate across the manuscript?

Why this is important:

Consistency keeps the reader engaged and ensures that the story feels realistic. Inconsistent details can break immersion, causing readers to question the believability of your story.

Tighten Dialogue

Dialogue is one of the most challenging aspects of writing fiction. It needs to sound authentic while serving multiple functions --- revealing character, advancing the plot, and adding subtext. During your self-editing process, read through your dialogue with a critical ear. Does it sound natural? Does it reveal something about the characters or move the story forward? Cut out any fluff or unnecessary filler words.

Why this is important:

Tightening dialogue improves character development and pacing. Well-crafted dialogue also creates opportunities for tension, subtext, and humor, enriching the overall narrative.

Examine Sentence Structure and Variety

A monotonous sentence structure can make your writing feel flat. Review your sentences for variety. Mix up short, punchy sentences with longer, more complex ones to create rhythm. Pay attention to how the sentences flow from one to another. Also, vary your sentence beginnings to avoid repetitive patterns.

Why this is important:

Varying sentence structure adds rhythm and dynamics to your writing. It helps maintain the reader's interest and keeps the narrative from feeling monotonous.

Focus on Clarity and Precision

When writing fiction, it's easy to get caught up in descriptive language or poetic flourishes. However, clarity should always be a priority. Ensure that every scene, character action, and bit of dialogue is clear to the reader. If there's any ambiguity that could confuse or distract from the plot, revise it.

Why this is important:

Clear writing is essential for keeping readers engaged and ensuring they understand your characters' motivations and the plot's direction. While creativity is important, clarity ensures your message gets across effectively.

Get Feedback from Others

Once you've completed your self-editing process, it's important to get feedback from trusted readers or beta readers. While self-editing is a great first step, having fresh eyes on your work can reveal areas that you may have missed. Consider joining a critique group or hiring a professional editor for a second opinion.

Why this is important:

Feedback from others helps you see your work from a different perspective and spot issues you may have overlooked. Critiques from readers familiar with your genre can also provide valuable insights into what works and what doesn't.

Conclusion

Self-editing is an art that takes time and practice to perfect. By following this checklist, you'll be able to revise your fiction with a critical eye, turning your draft into a refined, engaging story. Remember that self-editing isn't just about correcting mistakes; it's about improving the overall quality of your writing. Through careful planning, attention to detail, and the willingness to make tough changes, you can transform your manuscript into a polished piece of fiction that resonates with readers.

View Product